FLE
DHS report admits air marshals 'overreacted' in airport shooting
Although the department claims otherwise publicly, a confidential internal report within the Department of Homeland Security admits air marshals “overreacted” when they gunned down a Florida man at Miami International Airport last week. The report, which may never be released publicly, confirms that preliminary interviews with witnesses conflict the statements of air marshals who claim Rigoberto Alpizar shouted he had a bomb as he stormed off a plane and up a jetway at the airport. “Although witness statements contain conflicting information, none of those interrogated following the incident collaborate any utterance by the suspect that he either possessed, or intended to detonate, an explosive device,” the report says. Publicly, DHS and the Air Marshal Service claim the two agents who brought down Alpizar in a hail of bullets from their 357 Sig Sauer handguns acted “within guidelines” for handling potential terrorist activities. But Alpizar, a 44-year-old naturalized American citizen from Costa Rica, suffered from bipolar disorder and had not taken his prescription medication to control the condition. The Home Depot employee who lived in Maitland, Florida, did not have a bomb and witnesses on the scene dispute the marshals’ claim that he shouted he did. “I can tell you, he never said a thing in that airplane; he never called out he had a bomb,” says fellow passenger Jorge Borelli, an Orlando architect. “He just wanted to get off the plane,” says passenger John McAlhany, He adds that Alpizar was “clearly agitated” but said nothing about a bomb. “I never heard the word 'bomb' until the FBI asked me: 'Did you hear the word bomb?'” McAlhany says other federal officers stormed onto plane, pointing guns at passangers and demanding they put their hands in front of them....
Air Marshal Service Under Scrutiny After Shooting
The Federal Air Marshal Service sends thousands of armed undercover agents into the skies each day. But now the service is facing more scrutiny than ever after marshals shot a Maitland, Fla., man to death Wednesday at Miami International Airport. Miami-Dade police are investigating the shooting, the first by marshals since before the terror attacks of 2001. But it's not the first time the program has come under scrutiny. Federal reports released since the program's rapid expansion after the Sept. 11 attacks found that background checks of agents were often too lenient, discipline problems existed among marshals and firearms testing was often inconsistent. A report by the Government Accountability Office released in November found that there were few opportunities for career expansion for marshals and that the program was failing to track and follow up on incidents that compromised marshals' anonymity. The latter problem was addressed, but it is unclear how TSA will keep qualified marshals on the job. An August 2004 report by the Department of Homeland Security's inspector general found the program experienced several problems. In 2002, flight marshals were cited for instances of improper flight conduct, lost or stolen equipment including weapons, failed training and sleeping on duty, according to the report....
Are Air Marshals Prepared to Handle Mentally Ill Passengers?
The death of a bipolar airline passenger at the hands of federal air marshals has raised questions about whether the people charged with preventing violence in the skies are adequately trained to handle mentally ill passengers. Several experts on mental illness and police training said they did not fault air marshals for fatally shooting Rigoberto Alpizar at Miami International Airport. But they suggested the Federal Air Marshal Service should re-examine how it trains marshals to deal with people who act erratically or irrationally due to mental illness or other brain disorders, such as Alzheimer's disease. "This guy was mentally disturbed; he wasn't a terrorist, and he didn't have a bomb and the air marshals took him down, which is what they are trained to do," said Andrew Thomas, an aviation analyst at the University of Akron in Ohio....
Marshals To Patrol Land, Sea Transport
Teams of undercover air marshals and uniformed law enforcement officers will fan out to bus and train stations, ferries, and mass transit facilities across the country this week in a new test program to conduct surveillance and "counter potential criminal terrorist activity in all modes of transportation," according to internal federal documents. According to internal Transportation Security Administration documents, the program calls for newly created "Visible Intermodal Protection and Response" teams -- called "Viper" teams -- to take positions in public areas along Amtrak's Northeast Corridor and Los Angeles rail lines; ferries in Washington state; and mass transit systems in Atlanta, Philadelphia and Baltimore. Viper teams will also patrol the Washington Metro system. A Viper team will consist of two air marshals, one TSA bomb-sniffing-canine team, one or two transportation security inspectors, one local law enforcement officer, and one other TSA employee. Some members of the team will be obvious to the traveling public and wear jackets bearing the TSA name on the back. Others will be plainclothes air marshals scanning the crowds for suspicious people. It is unclear how many Viper teams will be on patrol through the New Year holiday, but air marshal officials confirm that they will be at seven locations across the country....
Is the Pentagon spying on Americans?
A year ago, at a Quaker Meeting House in Lake Worth, Fla., a small group of activists met to plan a protest of military recruiting at local high schools. What they didn't know was that their meeting had come to the attention of the U.S. military. A secret 400-page Defense Department document obtained by NBC News lists the Lake Worth meeting as a “threat” and one of more than 1,500 “suspicious incidents” across the country over a recent 10-month period. “This peaceful, educationally oriented group being a threat is incredible,” says Evy Grachow, a member of the Florida group called The Truth Project. “This is incredible,” adds group member Rich Hersh. “It's an example of paranoia by our government,” he says. “We're not doing anything illegal.” The Defense Department document is the first inside look at how the U.S. military has stepped up intelligence collection inside this country since 9/11, which now includes the monitoring of peaceful anti-war and counter-military recruitment groups. “I think Americans should be concerned that the military, in fact, has reached too far,” says NBC News military analyst Bill Arkin. The Department of Defense declined repeated requests by NBC News for an interview. The DOD database obtained by NBC News includes nearly four dozen anti-war meetings or protests, including some that have taken place far from any military installation, post or recruitment center....
An 11th-hour drive to amend Patriot Act
An unusual coalition of lawmakers and activists opposed to parts of the USA Patriot Act is mounting a last push to persuade Congress to take more time before voting to extend some of the law's most controversial provisions. At issue is whether Congress has been rigorous enough in assessing how the Patriot Act - which the White House calls vital to its war on terror - has been implemented. Many lawmakers were stunned by recent press reports, denied but not corrected by the Justice Department, that the FBI has issued as many as 30,000 "national security letters" since the law was passed nearly unanimously in 2001. The letters order private and public entities to turn over records and other private data about Americans - and remain silent about it. In the run-up to a vote later this week on extending controversial provisions of the act, civil liberties and privacy groups released their own research, based largely on documents obtained through the Freedom of Information Act, that they say signals numerous reporting violations and lax oversight. "Congress should not reauthorize the Patriot Act until these questions are resolved," says Marc Rotenberg, executive director of the Electronic Privacy Information Center in Washington, which released FBI documents it had obtained, at a press briefing Tuesday. On paper, the coalition urging a delay is the strongest to lobby Congress on any issue. Its backers range from conservative and libertarian groups - including the American Conservative Union, Americans for Tax Reform, and gun groups - to the American Civil Liberties Union. Within the Senate, a bipartisan group of lawmakers looking to tighten privacy protections wants to put off the vote for three months. (Parts of the Patriot Act are set to expire this month.) If these concerns aren't met, some, including Sens. Russell Feingold (D) of Wisconsin and Larry Craig (R) of Idaho, threaten to filibuster the bill....
Senate bill seeks time to tighten Patriot Act
A bipartisan coalition of senators yesterday introduced a bill to extend by three months controversial provisions of the USA Patriot Act to allow for efforts in the Senate and House to draft new legislation -- potentially trumping plans to vote this week on a four-year extension. The bill, authored by Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, Massachusetts Democrat, is co-sponsored by Democratic Sens. Patrick J. Leahy of Vermont, John D. Rockefeller IV of West Virginia, Carl Levin of Michigan and Richard J. Durbin of Illinois, along with Republican Sens. John E. Sununu of New Hampshire, Larry E. Craig of Idaho and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska. The senators told Sen. Arlen Specter, Pennsylvania Republican and chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, that the House waited six months to appoint members to the conference committee that made the Patriot Act recommendations and that "rushed negotiations won't be able to achieve a satisfactory resolution in the few days remaining in the session."....
New law will create domestic intelligence chief
The law renewing the USA PATRIOT Act will create a new official in the Justice Department responsible for domestic intelligence-gathering. Section 506 of the law, which is currently before Congress, establishes a National Security Division within the Department of Justice, to be headed by an Assistant Attorney General for National Security. The section implements a recommendation by the president's commission on intelligence that the Justice Department's "primary national security elements -- the Office of Intelligence Policy and Review, and the Counterterrorism and Counterespionage sections" be rolled into a single office, under the command of a new assistant attorney general. The new assistant attorney general will be nominated by the president after consultation with the director of national intelligence. The post-holder will be subject to confirmation by the judiciary committee and will report to the attorney general....
Wednesday, December 14, 2005
Tuesday, December 13, 2005
FLE
Woman handcuffed over swing set tiff
A Georgia woman was handcuffed and detained at her home by National Park Rangers after an argument over her family's swing set. Rangers said the swing set is on Chattahoochee River National Recreation Area property, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported. Kevin Cheri, superintendent for the park, said two of his officers were making routine inspections around the park when they noticed a homeowner's swing set on park property. The officers went to speak with Schelly Gettings to explain that the swing set had to be removed or put on her property, Cheri said. Cheri said Gettings became abusive toward the officers. "She was out of control," he said. "They were asking her to please calm down. She shoved one of the officers. He put handcuffs on her to protect himself and her....It's crossing the line when you touch an officer of the law."....
Airport ID checks legally enforced?
A federal appeals court wrestled Thursday with what seems to be a straightforward question: Can Americans be required to show ID on a commercial airline flight? John Gilmore, an early employee of Sun Microsystems and co-founder of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, says the answer should be "no." The libertarian millionaire sued the Bush administration, which claims that the ID requirement is necessary for security but has refused to identify any actual regulation requiring it. A three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals seemed skeptical of the Bush administration's defense of secret laws and regulations but stopped short of suggesting that such a rule would be necessarily unconstitutional. "How do we know there's an order?" Judge Thomas Nelson asked. "Because you said there was?" Replied Joshua Waldman, a staff attorney for the Department of Justice: "We couldn't confirm or deny the existence of an order." Even though government regulations required his silence, Waldman said, the situation did seem a "bit peculiar." "This is America," said James Harrison, a lawyer representing Gilmore. "We do not have secret laws. Period." Harrison stressed that Gilmore was happy to go through a metal detector....
MINIATURE GOLF COURSE MADE HOMELAND SECURITY WATCH LIST
Mini-golfers, calm down and tee up -- Emerald Hills Golfland is off the feds' terrorist-target list. Or is it? Some time back, officials added the humble South San Jose theme park -- ``three acres, two mini golf courses, very challenging,'' says Golfland's VP Bob Kenney -- to their National Asset Database. Local officials, figuring plenty of other Silicon Valley sites were richer targets, burst out laughing when they saw it. ``The moment we realized it was on the list, it was taken off,'' said San Jose police officer Rubens Dalaison, who handles ``critical infrastructure assessment'' for the department. ``I myself took it off.'' Then again, the list remains top secret. So who really knows? The terrorist-watchers at Homeland Security did not return several phone calls. And no one locally seems to know how Golfland got on the list to begin with....
US terror watchlist 80,000 names long
A watchlist of possible terror suspects distributed by the US government to airlines for pre-flight checks is now 80,000 names long, a Swedish newspaper reported, citing European air industry sources. The classified list, which carried just 16 names before the September 11, 2001 attacks in New York and Washington had grown to 1,000 by the end of 2001, to 40,000 a year later and now stands at 80,000, Svenska Dagbladet reported. Airlines must check each passenger flying to a US destination against the list, and contact the US Department of Homeland Security for further investigation if there is a matching name. The list contains a strict "no fly" section, which requires airline staff to contact police, and a "selectee" section, which requires passengers to undergo further security checks....
30,000 fliers seek terror watch-list removal
Nearly 30,000 airline passengers in the past year asked the Homeland Security Department to remove their names from terrorist watch lists, and all but about 60 were successful, Transportation Security Administration officials said. None of the passengers listed was ever prevented from flying, but some were selected for additional screening ranging from questioning to strip searches, Transportation Security Administration (TSA) officials said. "That number reflects the number of passengers that TSA has been able to provide relief to, whose names were the same or similar to those who actually appear on the no-flight or selectee list," said Yolanda Clark, chief spokeswoman for the TSA, an agency within the Homeland Security Department. Marcia Hofmann, director of the Electronic Privacy Information Center's open-government project, said the number of passengers asking to be delisted is "greater than anybody anticipated," and shows "the watch-list process doesn't work the way it is supposed to."....
FBI put peaceful protesters in terrorism files
The names and license plate numbers of about 30 people who protested three years ago in Colorado Springs were put into FBI domestic-terrorism files, the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of Colorado says. The Denver-based ACLU obtained federal documents on a 2002 Colorado Springs protest and a 2003 anti-war rally under the Freedom of Information Act. ACLU legal director Mark Silverstein said the documents show the FBI's Joint Terrorism Task Force wastes resources generating files on "nonviolent protest." "These documents confirm that the names and license plate numbers of several dozen peaceful protesters who committed no crime are now in a JTTF file marked 'counterterrorism,'" he said. "This kind of surveillance of First Amendment activities has serious consequences. Law-abiding Americans may be reluctant to speak out when doing so means that their names will wind up in an FBI file." FBI Special Agent Monique Kelso, the spokeswoman for the agency in Colorado, disputed the claim the task force wastes resources gathering information on protesters....
Live Tracking of Mobile Phones Prompts Court Fights on Privacy
Most Americans carry cellphones, but many may not know that government agencies can track their movements through the signals emanating from the handset. In recent years, law enforcement officials have turned to cellular technology as a tool for easily and secretly monitoring the movements of suspects as they occur. But this kind of surveillance - which investigators have been able to conduct with easily obtained court orders - has now come under tougher legal scrutiny. In the last four months, three federal judges have denied prosecutors the right to get cellphone tracking information from wireless companies without first showing "probable cause" to believe that a crime has been or is being committed. That is the same standard applied to requests for search warrants. The rulings, issued by magistrate judges in New York, Texas and Maryland, underscore the growing debate over privacy rights and government surveillance in the digital age. Not surprisingly, law enforcement agencies want to exploit this technology, too - which means more courts are bound to wrestle with what legal standard applies when government agents ask to conduct such surveillance. Cellular operators like Verizon Wireless and Cingular Wireless know, within about 300 yards, the location of their subscribers whenever a phone is turned on. Even if the phone is not in use it is communicating with cellphone tower sites, and the wireless provider keeps track of the phone's position as it travels. The operators have said that they turn over location information when presented with a court order to do so. The recent rulings by the magistrates, who are appointed by a majority of the federal district judges in a given court, do not bind other courts. But they could significantly curtail access to cell location data if other jurisdictions adopt the same reasoning. (The government's requests in the three cases, with their details, were sealed because they involve investigations still under way.)....
Defense Facilities Pass Along Reports of Suspicious Activity
Day after day, reports of suspicious activity filed from military bases and other defense installations throughout the United States flow into the Counterintelligence Field Activity, or CIFA, a three-year-old Pentagon agency whose size and budget remain classified. The Talon reports, as they are called, are based on information from civilians and military personnel who stumble across people or information they think might be part of a terrorist plot or threat against defense facilities at home or abroad. The documents can consist of "raw information reported by concerned citizens and military members regarding suspicious incidents," said a 2003 memo signed by then-Deputy Defense Secretary Paul D. Wolfowitz. The reports "may or may not be related to an actual threat, and its very nature may be fragmented and incomplete," the memo said. The Talon system is part of the Defense Department's growing effort to gather intelligence within the United States, which officials argue is imperative as they work to detect and prevent potentially catastrophic terrorist assaults. The Talon reports -- how many are generated is classified, a Pentagon spokesman said -- are collected and analyzed by CIFA, an agency at the forefront of the Pentagon's counterterrorism program....
Bush Says Congress Needs to Act Quickly to Extend Patriot Act
U.S. President George W. Bush called on Congress to quickly renew the USA Patriot Act, saying that the law's expiration at the end of this month might lead to terrorist violence. ``The terrorist threats will not expire on that schedule,'' Bush said in his weekly radio address. ``In the war on terror, we cannot afford to be without that vital law for a single moment.'' Congressional negotiators reached an agreement this week on a four-year extension of the expansion of powers by federal officials to investigate suspected terrorists, clearing the way for a vote next week. The law was passed in the wake of the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. Critics in Congress have expressed disappointment in the law and have called for further changes before a vote is held. Opposition by a bipartisan group of six senators has left the bill's fate in some doubt, with at least one calling for a possible filibuster, just weeks before the law is to expire....
ACLU Opposes Patriot Act Provision
The American Civil Liberties Union raised objections yesterday to a little-noticed provision of the latest version of the USA Patriot Act bill, arguing that it would give the Secret Service wider latitude to charge protesters accused of disrupting major events including political conventions and the Olympics. But Sen. Arlen Specter (R-Pa.), who sponsored the provisions, and his aides said the concerns are misguided. The changes are meant to clear up legal confusion about the Secret Service's role at major events and to ensure that venues are fully secure before the president or other top officials arrive, they said. "I'm a little surprised at the concern," Specter said in an interview, adding later, "The venue needs to be subject to their jurisdiction to make sure it's okay." The measure is the latest point of contention in a GOP-approved conference bill that would make permanent most parts of the Patriot Act anti-terrorism law and would renew two other provisions for four years. A bipartisan group has vowed to fight the proposal, and several lawmakers proposed legislation yesterday that would give Congress an additional three months to negotiate. The Secret Service is authorized to charge suspects with breaching security or disruptive behavior at National Special Security Events, but only if the president or another person under the protection of the service is in attendance, according to a legislative summary. The bill adds language prohibiting people from "willfully and knowingly" entering a restricted area "where the President or other person protected by the Secret Service is or will be temporarily visiting." The measure also applies to security breaches "in conjunction with an event designated as a special event of national significance," according to the bill. Penalties for such violations would increase from six months to a year in prison....
At F.B.I., Frustration Over Limits on an Antiterror Law
Some agents at the Federal Bureau of Investigation have been frustrated by what they see as the Justice Department's reluctance to let them demand records and to use other far-ranging investigative measures in terrorism cases, newly disclosed e-mail messages and internal documents show. Publicly, the debate over the law known as the USA Patriot Act has focused on concerns from civil rights advocates that the F.B.I. has gained too much power to use expanded investigative tools to go on what could amount to fishing expeditions. But the newly disclosed e-mail messages offer a competing view, showing that, privately, some F.B.I. agents have felt hamstrung by their inability to get approval for using new powers under the Patriot Act, which was passed weeks after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. One internal F.B.I. message, sent in October 2003, criticized the Office of Intelligence Policy and Review at the Justice Department, which reviews and approves terrorist warrants, as regularly blocking requests from the F.B.I. to use a section of the antiterrorism law that gave the bureau broader authority to demand records from institutions like banks, Internet providers and libraries....
How planespotters turned into the scourge of the CIA
Paul last saw the Gulfstream V about 18 months ago. He comes down to Glasgow airport's planespotters' club most days. He had not seen the plane before so he marked the serial number down in his book. At the time, he did not think there was anything unusual about the Gulfstream being ushered to a stand away from public view, one that could not be seen from the airport terminal or the club's prime view. But that flight this week was at the centre of a transatlantic row that saw the prime minister being put on the spot on the floor of the House of Commons and the US secretary of state, Condoleezza Rice, forced on the defensive during a visit to Europe. The Gulfstream V has been identified as having been used by the CIA for "extraordinary renditions" - abducting terror suspects and taking them to secret prisons around the world where they may be tortured. The recording of flights by spotters like Paul from places as far afield as Bournemouth and Karachi has unintentionally played a significant role in helping journalists and human rights groups expose the scale of the CIA's renditions system. But his impact on such international intrigue largely passes Paul by. "It's not the CIA bit that interests us. You don't even know who owns the plane when you take down the serial number," he said, already distracted as something comes in to land through the grey drizzle. "You keep accurate logs, for your own records."....
Woman handcuffed over swing set tiff
A Georgia woman was handcuffed and detained at her home by National Park Rangers after an argument over her family's swing set. Rangers said the swing set is on Chattahoochee River National Recreation Area property, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported. Kevin Cheri, superintendent for the park, said two of his officers were making routine inspections around the park when they noticed a homeowner's swing set on park property. The officers went to speak with Schelly Gettings to explain that the swing set had to be removed or put on her property, Cheri said. Cheri said Gettings became abusive toward the officers. "She was out of control," he said. "They were asking her to please calm down. She shoved one of the officers. He put handcuffs on her to protect himself and her....It's crossing the line when you touch an officer of the law."....
Airport ID checks legally enforced?
A federal appeals court wrestled Thursday with what seems to be a straightforward question: Can Americans be required to show ID on a commercial airline flight? John Gilmore, an early employee of Sun Microsystems and co-founder of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, says the answer should be "no." The libertarian millionaire sued the Bush administration, which claims that the ID requirement is necessary for security but has refused to identify any actual regulation requiring it. A three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals seemed skeptical of the Bush administration's defense of secret laws and regulations but stopped short of suggesting that such a rule would be necessarily unconstitutional. "How do we know there's an order?" Judge Thomas Nelson asked. "Because you said there was?" Replied Joshua Waldman, a staff attorney for the Department of Justice: "We couldn't confirm or deny the existence of an order." Even though government regulations required his silence, Waldman said, the situation did seem a "bit peculiar." "This is America," said James Harrison, a lawyer representing Gilmore. "We do not have secret laws. Period." Harrison stressed that Gilmore was happy to go through a metal detector....
MINIATURE GOLF COURSE MADE HOMELAND SECURITY WATCH LIST
Mini-golfers, calm down and tee up -- Emerald Hills Golfland is off the feds' terrorist-target list. Or is it? Some time back, officials added the humble South San Jose theme park -- ``three acres, two mini golf courses, very challenging,'' says Golfland's VP Bob Kenney -- to their National Asset Database. Local officials, figuring plenty of other Silicon Valley sites were richer targets, burst out laughing when they saw it. ``The moment we realized it was on the list, it was taken off,'' said San Jose police officer Rubens Dalaison, who handles ``critical infrastructure assessment'' for the department. ``I myself took it off.'' Then again, the list remains top secret. So who really knows? The terrorist-watchers at Homeland Security did not return several phone calls. And no one locally seems to know how Golfland got on the list to begin with....
US terror watchlist 80,000 names long
A watchlist of possible terror suspects distributed by the US government to airlines for pre-flight checks is now 80,000 names long, a Swedish newspaper reported, citing European air industry sources. The classified list, which carried just 16 names before the September 11, 2001 attacks in New York and Washington had grown to 1,000 by the end of 2001, to 40,000 a year later and now stands at 80,000, Svenska Dagbladet reported. Airlines must check each passenger flying to a US destination against the list, and contact the US Department of Homeland Security for further investigation if there is a matching name. The list contains a strict "no fly" section, which requires airline staff to contact police, and a "selectee" section, which requires passengers to undergo further security checks....
30,000 fliers seek terror watch-list removal
Nearly 30,000 airline passengers in the past year asked the Homeland Security Department to remove their names from terrorist watch lists, and all but about 60 were successful, Transportation Security Administration officials said. None of the passengers listed was ever prevented from flying, but some were selected for additional screening ranging from questioning to strip searches, Transportation Security Administration (TSA) officials said. "That number reflects the number of passengers that TSA has been able to provide relief to, whose names were the same or similar to those who actually appear on the no-flight or selectee list," said Yolanda Clark, chief spokeswoman for the TSA, an agency within the Homeland Security Department. Marcia Hofmann, director of the Electronic Privacy Information Center's open-government project, said the number of passengers asking to be delisted is "greater than anybody anticipated," and shows "the watch-list process doesn't work the way it is supposed to."....
FBI put peaceful protesters in terrorism files
The names and license plate numbers of about 30 people who protested three years ago in Colorado Springs were put into FBI domestic-terrorism files, the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of Colorado says. The Denver-based ACLU obtained federal documents on a 2002 Colorado Springs protest and a 2003 anti-war rally under the Freedom of Information Act. ACLU legal director Mark Silverstein said the documents show the FBI's Joint Terrorism Task Force wastes resources generating files on "nonviolent protest." "These documents confirm that the names and license plate numbers of several dozen peaceful protesters who committed no crime are now in a JTTF file marked 'counterterrorism,'" he said. "This kind of surveillance of First Amendment activities has serious consequences. Law-abiding Americans may be reluctant to speak out when doing so means that their names will wind up in an FBI file." FBI Special Agent Monique Kelso, the spokeswoman for the agency in Colorado, disputed the claim the task force wastes resources gathering information on protesters....
Live Tracking of Mobile Phones Prompts Court Fights on Privacy
Most Americans carry cellphones, but many may not know that government agencies can track their movements through the signals emanating from the handset. In recent years, law enforcement officials have turned to cellular technology as a tool for easily and secretly monitoring the movements of suspects as they occur. But this kind of surveillance - which investigators have been able to conduct with easily obtained court orders - has now come under tougher legal scrutiny. In the last four months, three federal judges have denied prosecutors the right to get cellphone tracking information from wireless companies without first showing "probable cause" to believe that a crime has been or is being committed. That is the same standard applied to requests for search warrants. The rulings, issued by magistrate judges in New York, Texas and Maryland, underscore the growing debate over privacy rights and government surveillance in the digital age. Not surprisingly, law enforcement agencies want to exploit this technology, too - which means more courts are bound to wrestle with what legal standard applies when government agents ask to conduct such surveillance. Cellular operators like Verizon Wireless and Cingular Wireless know, within about 300 yards, the location of their subscribers whenever a phone is turned on. Even if the phone is not in use it is communicating with cellphone tower sites, and the wireless provider keeps track of the phone's position as it travels. The operators have said that they turn over location information when presented with a court order to do so. The recent rulings by the magistrates, who are appointed by a majority of the federal district judges in a given court, do not bind other courts. But they could significantly curtail access to cell location data if other jurisdictions adopt the same reasoning. (The government's requests in the three cases, with their details, were sealed because they involve investigations still under way.)....
Defense Facilities Pass Along Reports of Suspicious Activity
Day after day, reports of suspicious activity filed from military bases and other defense installations throughout the United States flow into the Counterintelligence Field Activity, or CIFA, a three-year-old Pentagon agency whose size and budget remain classified. The Talon reports, as they are called, are based on information from civilians and military personnel who stumble across people or information they think might be part of a terrorist plot or threat against defense facilities at home or abroad. The documents can consist of "raw information reported by concerned citizens and military members regarding suspicious incidents," said a 2003 memo signed by then-Deputy Defense Secretary Paul D. Wolfowitz. The reports "may or may not be related to an actual threat, and its very nature may be fragmented and incomplete," the memo said. The Talon system is part of the Defense Department's growing effort to gather intelligence within the United States, which officials argue is imperative as they work to detect and prevent potentially catastrophic terrorist assaults. The Talon reports -- how many are generated is classified, a Pentagon spokesman said -- are collected and analyzed by CIFA, an agency at the forefront of the Pentagon's counterterrorism program....
Bush Says Congress Needs to Act Quickly to Extend Patriot Act
U.S. President George W. Bush called on Congress to quickly renew the USA Patriot Act, saying that the law's expiration at the end of this month might lead to terrorist violence. ``The terrorist threats will not expire on that schedule,'' Bush said in his weekly radio address. ``In the war on terror, we cannot afford to be without that vital law for a single moment.'' Congressional negotiators reached an agreement this week on a four-year extension of the expansion of powers by federal officials to investigate suspected terrorists, clearing the way for a vote next week. The law was passed in the wake of the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. Critics in Congress have expressed disappointment in the law and have called for further changes before a vote is held. Opposition by a bipartisan group of six senators has left the bill's fate in some doubt, with at least one calling for a possible filibuster, just weeks before the law is to expire....
ACLU Opposes Patriot Act Provision
The American Civil Liberties Union raised objections yesterday to a little-noticed provision of the latest version of the USA Patriot Act bill, arguing that it would give the Secret Service wider latitude to charge protesters accused of disrupting major events including political conventions and the Olympics. But Sen. Arlen Specter (R-Pa.), who sponsored the provisions, and his aides said the concerns are misguided. The changes are meant to clear up legal confusion about the Secret Service's role at major events and to ensure that venues are fully secure before the president or other top officials arrive, they said. "I'm a little surprised at the concern," Specter said in an interview, adding later, "The venue needs to be subject to their jurisdiction to make sure it's okay." The measure is the latest point of contention in a GOP-approved conference bill that would make permanent most parts of the Patriot Act anti-terrorism law and would renew two other provisions for four years. A bipartisan group has vowed to fight the proposal, and several lawmakers proposed legislation yesterday that would give Congress an additional three months to negotiate. The Secret Service is authorized to charge suspects with breaching security or disruptive behavior at National Special Security Events, but only if the president or another person under the protection of the service is in attendance, according to a legislative summary. The bill adds language prohibiting people from "willfully and knowingly" entering a restricted area "where the President or other person protected by the Secret Service is or will be temporarily visiting." The measure also applies to security breaches "in conjunction with an event designated as a special event of national significance," according to the bill. Penalties for such violations would increase from six months to a year in prison....
At F.B.I., Frustration Over Limits on an Antiterror Law
Some agents at the Federal Bureau of Investigation have been frustrated by what they see as the Justice Department's reluctance to let them demand records and to use other far-ranging investigative measures in terrorism cases, newly disclosed e-mail messages and internal documents show. Publicly, the debate over the law known as the USA Patriot Act has focused on concerns from civil rights advocates that the F.B.I. has gained too much power to use expanded investigative tools to go on what could amount to fishing expeditions. But the newly disclosed e-mail messages offer a competing view, showing that, privately, some F.B.I. agents have felt hamstrung by their inability to get approval for using new powers under the Patriot Act, which was passed weeks after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. One internal F.B.I. message, sent in October 2003, criticized the Office of Intelligence Policy and Review at the Justice Department, which reviews and approves terrorist warrants, as regularly blocking requests from the F.B.I. to use a section of the antiterrorism law that gave the bureau broader authority to demand records from institutions like banks, Internet providers and libraries....
How planespotters turned into the scourge of the CIA
Paul last saw the Gulfstream V about 18 months ago. He comes down to Glasgow airport's planespotters' club most days. He had not seen the plane before so he marked the serial number down in his book. At the time, he did not think there was anything unusual about the Gulfstream being ushered to a stand away from public view, one that could not be seen from the airport terminal or the club's prime view. But that flight this week was at the centre of a transatlantic row that saw the prime minister being put on the spot on the floor of the House of Commons and the US secretary of state, Condoleezza Rice, forced on the defensive during a visit to Europe. The Gulfstream V has been identified as having been used by the CIA for "extraordinary renditions" - abducting terror suspects and taking them to secret prisons around the world where they may be tortured. The recording of flights by spotters like Paul from places as far afield as Bournemouth and Karachi has unintentionally played a significant role in helping journalists and human rights groups expose the scale of the CIA's renditions system. But his impact on such international intrigue largely passes Paul by. "It's not the CIA bit that interests us. You don't even know who owns the plane when you take down the serial number," he said, already distracted as something comes in to land through the grey drizzle. "You keep accurate logs, for your own records."....
NEWS ROUNDUP
Forest Service Stops Mining Due To Bat Dwelling The U.S. Forest Service recently ordered a miner to stop his activities in a centuries old mine because it's being used as a roosting habitat by the rare Townsend's Big-eared Bat. The bat, listed as a "species of viability concern," has taken up residence in the Maree Love mine, which is connected to a hot vapor cave, wildlife biologist Phil Nyland said Monday. Robert Congdon, who holds claims to the mine's underground minerals, can no longer explore the cave until the agency performs a historical inventory and bat habitat study, according to Aspen District Ranger Bill Westbrook....
Alliance seeks to stem wild horse births It's birth control for wild horses who prove fertile in their free-roaming lives on the nation's Western countryside. It's developed from pig ovaries and injected in a mare's hips. Called PZP, the contraceptive gave birth to an agreement between a federal agency and the Humane Society of the United States at a meeting late last month in Santa Fe. The Bureau of Land Management and the Humane Society announced they would work together to further development and use of PZP on mares living on federal land in 10 Western states. New Mexico's Socorro County is home to one BLM herd but, at about 70 horses, it's too small to merit use of a contraceptive. The U.S. Forest Service, which manages two larger herds in the Carson National Forest, is intrigued with the idea and sent representatives to the Santa Fe meeting....
Taking the pulse of climate change in the Colorado Rockies The marmot was holding his own until the second coyote blindsided him. The coarse-furred, groundhog-like rodent emerged from his hibernation burrow last April onto a thick crust of snow that blanketed this former mining town several miles north of Crested Butte. A band of coyotes had been hanging around, and one of them pounced on the marmot. The feisty rodent rose to his hind legs and batted at the coyote with his clawed front paws, like a boxer, as he struggled to escape. But a second coyote bounded in from behind and joined the fray. The two canines killed the marmot, then dragged him off. To University of Maryland ecologist David Inouye, this grisly account serves as a cautionary tale about — believe it or not — the potential perils of global climate change....
Efforts to protect orcas may have wide impact What do chemicals you wash down the drain, Navy ships, a proposed Maury Island gravel mine and an international treaty have in common? Each could be affected by the recent protection of Puget Sound killer whales under the Endangered Species Act. Early next year comes the first step in determining how much punch the "endangered" label will carry for the oft-ogled orcas. Federal officials are asking the public to speak up in the next few weeks. The National Marine Fisheries Service, which has released a proposed conservation plan, hopes the new listing will lead to better safeguards against oil spills -- the biggest single extinction threat for the orca. The agency is also raising the prospect of tighter controls on development in sensitive areas and restrictions on emerging chemical threats....
White House pushes Congress on Alaska drilling Bush administration officials on Monday urged Congress to include opening Alaska's Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil drilling in a broad budget-cutting bill that could see a vote this week. ANWR drilling is one of several politically sensitive items that will be in play when Senate and House negotiators try to finalize legislation to cut federal government spending by at least $35 billion over five years. The Senate included ANWR in its package of spending cuts. But the House-passed budget bill dropped the ANWR drilling provision after a group of moderate Republicans threatened to vote against the measure if the drilling language was included. The Bush administration stepped up its lobbying efforts to give oil companies access to the refuge....
BLM: PFS can make case for nuke storage in new comment period A federal Bureau of Land Management official said Monday that Sen. Orrin Hatch's assessment that Private Fuel Storage was falling apart played a role in his decision to seek new public comments about the company's plans to build a temporary nuclear waste storage facility in Utah's Skull Valley. Private Fuel Storage, a coalition of eight utilities, plans to use the Skull Valley Goshute Indian Reservation as a temporary way station for nuclear waste pending work at Yucca Mountain, the site of a proposed nuclear waste dump 90 miles northwest Las Vegas. The BLM must sign off on rights of way to access the Skull Valley site. Hatch, R-Utah, who wants to kill the proposed storage facility, had argued that seven of the eight utilities had agreed to suspend their funding for the project, calling into question the company's future....
Wasted Colo. River water at issue No matter how many pipelines, pumps and dams Western states build along the Colorado River, billions of gallons of water will never make it to the farms and growing cities that need it. That water instead seeps into the ground through unlined canals and ditches, escapes downstream when users can't take it as planned or is sucked up by trees, bushes and other vegetation along the river's 1,450-mile course. To water managers in the seven river states, that is wasted water. With demand growing and the supply limited, or even shrinking in drought years, the states want to reduce the waste as much as they can. They are studying a range of ideas, from pulling weeds to lining canals, as part of a broader plan to deal with future shortages....
Officials to meet about future of Colorado River use Interior Secretary Gale Norton is scheduled to speak at a meeting of Colorado River water users in Las Vegas next week, capping three days of potentially tough interstate discussions on managing the river's resource. The issues to be discussed are dividing the four states of the upper Colorado River basin from the three lower basin states. But Nevada, California and Arizona, the three lower basin states, have their own disagreements. Hanging over next week's meetings and the overall debate is a federal deadline to come up with a way to manage feared shortages of water on the river because of drought. Officials in Nevada and Washington said Norton _ the manager of the critical river system for more than 20 million people in the Southwest _ plans to speak Dec. 16. Listening closely to Norton will be a host of state representatives, water-agency managers, tribal leaders, environmentalists, private sector contractors and others with an interest in the region's water future....
Lake Powell still a glass half-empty Flows into Lake Powell were slightly above average this year, but the giant reservoir in Utah remains far from full, officials with the Bureau of Reclamation say. In 2005, flows into the reservoir were about 105 percent of average. Even with that increase, Lake Powell is only about half- full, holding 12 million acre-feet of water. The drought of 2002 decimated Lake Powell, which acts like a water bank for the upper basin states of Colorado, Wyoming, New Mexico and Utah, releasing water to Lake Mead for distribution to the lower basin as required under the 1922 Colorado River Compact. Flows in Lake Powell in 2002 were 25 percent of average - the lowest they had been since the completion of the Glen Canyon Dam in 1963....
'Elvis' woodpecker draws searchers It has starred in a video, been widely recorded and graced the cover of a prestigious magazine. But to dispel any doubt the ivory-billed woodpecker -- the Elvis of the bird world -- is back from extinction, searchers are combing a corner of Arkansas in an intensive six-month hunt. On foot, in canoes and kayaks, even using cherry-picker vehicles that tower over the forest canopy, teams of volunteers and paid workers have been looking for traces of the big bird in the forests and swamps of the White River and Cache River basins, just west of the Mississippi. "The thrust of it is to find out more: find the birds and then learn more about what they do, how they live, where their habitat is, how many there are," said Jon Andrew of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which is working with conservation groups and academic experts in the search....
Tribal chairman says water plan overlooks western North Dakota Three Affiliated Tribes Chairman Tex Hall says the tribes and western North Dakota generally are being overlooked in plans to pipe Missouri River water to the Red River Valley in times of drought. ''Nobody's talked to us [about the Red River plan], so we don't know how much water would be diverted,'' Hall said. ''I'm not saying we're against it, I'm just saying we haven't been adequately consulted here,'' he said. ''I'm alarmed that we're not getting consulted on this huge initiative.'' The plan, endorsed by the State Water Commission, would build a pipeline to connect with the McClusky Canal near McClusky and move Missouri River water east to Lake Ashtabula, near Valley City, for storage after treating it. Water would be released as needed into the Sheyenne River, which flows into the Red River north of Fargo. The project, which still must go through federal review, could cost up to $660 million to build. Fargo Mayor Bruce Furness compared it to taking a thimbleful of water out of a five-gallon pail during drought times, with the pail representing the Missouri River....
Teen, horse she helped raise in world championship Boons Cowboy had an attitude problem from the very beginning. Maybe it was his difficult birth. Maybe it was a stubborn streak he inherited from a parent. Maybe it was because he was called a cull and a spitfire. Whatever the reason, there were few who expected Kathryn McMurray's 3-year-old American quarter horse to ever have enough cow sense to be a cutter, a horse trained to single out a cow from its herd. But McMurray, a 16-year-old from Kingsport, and Boons Cowboy are in Fort Worth, Texas, today, having just competed in the 2005 National Cutting Horse Association's World Championship Futurity. Boons Cowboy was Kathryn's first delivery, born May 2, 2002, when Kathryn was 13 years old....
Slow dancin’ It’s a reemerging art of inches and angles. A lowered head; a tilted shoulder; and slow, controlled movements are some of the postures used in traditional hackamore horse training. “A non-horse person quite often looks at some of our training like it’s a dance,” said traditional hackamore horse trainer R.E. Smith. Smith and his wife Laurie run Circle S Ranch in Corning. The couple travels all over the West about 12 weeks out of the year conducting hackamore horse training clinics as well as producing training videos and DVDs with their Circle S Productions. “It’s the way that the old vaquero rode 260 years ago,” said Smith in a phone interview from Descanso where he was giving a presentation during Vaquero Days. The hackamore is a bit-less bridle that includes the hanger, bosal and macate, a 22-foot-long horse-hair rope....
Georgia dairy farmer wins world all-around title Dairy cows don't wait. Not even for world all-around champions. Ryan Jarrett, of Summerville, Ga., runs a 750-acre dairy farm with his father DeJuan in northwest Georgia. The cows will still need tending when Jarrett returns from the National Finals Rodeo. “I can't wait,” said the younger Jarrett of returning home. While the work for the cows remains the same, Jarrett does not. He returns to the farm as the 2005 PRCA world all-around champion. He is the first cowboy from Georgia - and the first from east of the Mississippi River - to win professional rodeo's most prestigious title. Jarrett, who turns 22 on Dec. 28, earned a total of $263,664 for the year in steer wrestling, tie-down roping and as a team roping header. He won $114,717 at the 10-performance National Finals Rodeo that concluded Sunday afternoon. Jarrett was the only two-event qualifier, competing in both steer wrestling and tie-down roping....
Wills Point bull rider wins with record haul Bull rider Matt Austin exceeded even his dreams. Austin, from Wills Point, Texas, said his goal this year was to win the world championship. Well, he accomplished that two days ago before the Wrangler National Finals Rodeo was completed. On Sunday, after riding Razor Sharp out of the Growney Brothers Rodeo for 88.5 points, he scaled another plateau. He finished second in the round and earned the aggregate title to become the all-time one-year earnings leader in pro rodeo, finishing the year with $320,765. That broke Ty Murray's mark of $297,896 in three events in 1983. Austin's record came in only one event, and he's the first cowboy to cross the $300,000 mark in one year. Austin joined four other Texans in the winners circle at the Thomas & Mack Center, with Fred Whitfield of Hockley winning his eighth tie-down roping title, Will Lowe of Canyon and Kelly Kaminski of Bellville winning their second championships in bareback riding and barrel racing, respectively, and Patrick Smith of Midland earning his first world heeling title....
It's All Trew: Problems build character for young I looked back into my early life for a comparable experience. The closest I could come was solving problems associated with building a slingshot. The materials were wood, rubber strips for power, strong twine and a small piece of flexible leather. Simple enough until you got into the technological problems. The first problem came in selecting the proper wood. An old dry tree fork was simple and easy to find. A green fork would be stronger but required some cutting and peeling. Next came the rubber strips. Was red or black rubber the best? Did you cut the strips longwise or crosswise from the inner-tube? Determining the proper length of the rubber strips was probably the most difficult problem I had encountered in my young life. I was always forced to use whatever materials were available, often eliminating the choice problem. Of great importance was the quality, flexibility and strength of the leather used to hold the rock or, as it would be called today, the "missile." Whatever you did, you didn't cut the tongue out of your father's Sunday shoes!! Though perfect in form and flexibility, it just wasn't worth it. I can testify to this from experience....
Forest Service Stops Mining Due To Bat Dwelling The U.S. Forest Service recently ordered a miner to stop his activities in a centuries old mine because it's being used as a roosting habitat by the rare Townsend's Big-eared Bat. The bat, listed as a "species of viability concern," has taken up residence in the Maree Love mine, which is connected to a hot vapor cave, wildlife biologist Phil Nyland said Monday. Robert Congdon, who holds claims to the mine's underground minerals, can no longer explore the cave until the agency performs a historical inventory and bat habitat study, according to Aspen District Ranger Bill Westbrook....
Alliance seeks to stem wild horse births It's birth control for wild horses who prove fertile in their free-roaming lives on the nation's Western countryside. It's developed from pig ovaries and injected in a mare's hips. Called PZP, the contraceptive gave birth to an agreement between a federal agency and the Humane Society of the United States at a meeting late last month in Santa Fe. The Bureau of Land Management and the Humane Society announced they would work together to further development and use of PZP on mares living on federal land in 10 Western states. New Mexico's Socorro County is home to one BLM herd but, at about 70 horses, it's too small to merit use of a contraceptive. The U.S. Forest Service, which manages two larger herds in the Carson National Forest, is intrigued with the idea and sent representatives to the Santa Fe meeting....
Taking the pulse of climate change in the Colorado Rockies The marmot was holding his own until the second coyote blindsided him. The coarse-furred, groundhog-like rodent emerged from his hibernation burrow last April onto a thick crust of snow that blanketed this former mining town several miles north of Crested Butte. A band of coyotes had been hanging around, and one of them pounced on the marmot. The feisty rodent rose to his hind legs and batted at the coyote with his clawed front paws, like a boxer, as he struggled to escape. But a second coyote bounded in from behind and joined the fray. The two canines killed the marmot, then dragged him off. To University of Maryland ecologist David Inouye, this grisly account serves as a cautionary tale about — believe it or not — the potential perils of global climate change....
Efforts to protect orcas may have wide impact What do chemicals you wash down the drain, Navy ships, a proposed Maury Island gravel mine and an international treaty have in common? Each could be affected by the recent protection of Puget Sound killer whales under the Endangered Species Act. Early next year comes the first step in determining how much punch the "endangered" label will carry for the oft-ogled orcas. Federal officials are asking the public to speak up in the next few weeks. The National Marine Fisheries Service, which has released a proposed conservation plan, hopes the new listing will lead to better safeguards against oil spills -- the biggest single extinction threat for the orca. The agency is also raising the prospect of tighter controls on development in sensitive areas and restrictions on emerging chemical threats....
White House pushes Congress on Alaska drilling Bush administration officials on Monday urged Congress to include opening Alaska's Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil drilling in a broad budget-cutting bill that could see a vote this week. ANWR drilling is one of several politically sensitive items that will be in play when Senate and House negotiators try to finalize legislation to cut federal government spending by at least $35 billion over five years. The Senate included ANWR in its package of spending cuts. But the House-passed budget bill dropped the ANWR drilling provision after a group of moderate Republicans threatened to vote against the measure if the drilling language was included. The Bush administration stepped up its lobbying efforts to give oil companies access to the refuge....
BLM: PFS can make case for nuke storage in new comment period A federal Bureau of Land Management official said Monday that Sen. Orrin Hatch's assessment that Private Fuel Storage was falling apart played a role in his decision to seek new public comments about the company's plans to build a temporary nuclear waste storage facility in Utah's Skull Valley. Private Fuel Storage, a coalition of eight utilities, plans to use the Skull Valley Goshute Indian Reservation as a temporary way station for nuclear waste pending work at Yucca Mountain, the site of a proposed nuclear waste dump 90 miles northwest Las Vegas. The BLM must sign off on rights of way to access the Skull Valley site. Hatch, R-Utah, who wants to kill the proposed storage facility, had argued that seven of the eight utilities had agreed to suspend their funding for the project, calling into question the company's future....
Wasted Colo. River water at issue No matter how many pipelines, pumps and dams Western states build along the Colorado River, billions of gallons of water will never make it to the farms and growing cities that need it. That water instead seeps into the ground through unlined canals and ditches, escapes downstream when users can't take it as planned or is sucked up by trees, bushes and other vegetation along the river's 1,450-mile course. To water managers in the seven river states, that is wasted water. With demand growing and the supply limited, or even shrinking in drought years, the states want to reduce the waste as much as they can. They are studying a range of ideas, from pulling weeds to lining canals, as part of a broader plan to deal with future shortages....
Officials to meet about future of Colorado River use Interior Secretary Gale Norton is scheduled to speak at a meeting of Colorado River water users in Las Vegas next week, capping three days of potentially tough interstate discussions on managing the river's resource. The issues to be discussed are dividing the four states of the upper Colorado River basin from the three lower basin states. But Nevada, California and Arizona, the three lower basin states, have their own disagreements. Hanging over next week's meetings and the overall debate is a federal deadline to come up with a way to manage feared shortages of water on the river because of drought. Officials in Nevada and Washington said Norton _ the manager of the critical river system for more than 20 million people in the Southwest _ plans to speak Dec. 16. Listening closely to Norton will be a host of state representatives, water-agency managers, tribal leaders, environmentalists, private sector contractors and others with an interest in the region's water future....
Lake Powell still a glass half-empty Flows into Lake Powell were slightly above average this year, but the giant reservoir in Utah remains far from full, officials with the Bureau of Reclamation say. In 2005, flows into the reservoir were about 105 percent of average. Even with that increase, Lake Powell is only about half- full, holding 12 million acre-feet of water. The drought of 2002 decimated Lake Powell, which acts like a water bank for the upper basin states of Colorado, Wyoming, New Mexico and Utah, releasing water to Lake Mead for distribution to the lower basin as required under the 1922 Colorado River Compact. Flows in Lake Powell in 2002 were 25 percent of average - the lowest they had been since the completion of the Glen Canyon Dam in 1963....
'Elvis' woodpecker draws searchers It has starred in a video, been widely recorded and graced the cover of a prestigious magazine. But to dispel any doubt the ivory-billed woodpecker -- the Elvis of the bird world -- is back from extinction, searchers are combing a corner of Arkansas in an intensive six-month hunt. On foot, in canoes and kayaks, even using cherry-picker vehicles that tower over the forest canopy, teams of volunteers and paid workers have been looking for traces of the big bird in the forests and swamps of the White River and Cache River basins, just west of the Mississippi. "The thrust of it is to find out more: find the birds and then learn more about what they do, how they live, where their habitat is, how many there are," said Jon Andrew of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which is working with conservation groups and academic experts in the search....
Tribal chairman says water plan overlooks western North Dakota Three Affiliated Tribes Chairman Tex Hall says the tribes and western North Dakota generally are being overlooked in plans to pipe Missouri River water to the Red River Valley in times of drought. ''Nobody's talked to us [about the Red River plan], so we don't know how much water would be diverted,'' Hall said. ''I'm not saying we're against it, I'm just saying we haven't been adequately consulted here,'' he said. ''I'm alarmed that we're not getting consulted on this huge initiative.'' The plan, endorsed by the State Water Commission, would build a pipeline to connect with the McClusky Canal near McClusky and move Missouri River water east to Lake Ashtabula, near Valley City, for storage after treating it. Water would be released as needed into the Sheyenne River, which flows into the Red River north of Fargo. The project, which still must go through federal review, could cost up to $660 million to build. Fargo Mayor Bruce Furness compared it to taking a thimbleful of water out of a five-gallon pail during drought times, with the pail representing the Missouri River....
Teen, horse she helped raise in world championship Boons Cowboy had an attitude problem from the very beginning. Maybe it was his difficult birth. Maybe it was a stubborn streak he inherited from a parent. Maybe it was because he was called a cull and a spitfire. Whatever the reason, there were few who expected Kathryn McMurray's 3-year-old American quarter horse to ever have enough cow sense to be a cutter, a horse trained to single out a cow from its herd. But McMurray, a 16-year-old from Kingsport, and Boons Cowboy are in Fort Worth, Texas, today, having just competed in the 2005 National Cutting Horse Association's World Championship Futurity. Boons Cowboy was Kathryn's first delivery, born May 2, 2002, when Kathryn was 13 years old....
Slow dancin’ It’s a reemerging art of inches and angles. A lowered head; a tilted shoulder; and slow, controlled movements are some of the postures used in traditional hackamore horse training. “A non-horse person quite often looks at some of our training like it’s a dance,” said traditional hackamore horse trainer R.E. Smith. Smith and his wife Laurie run Circle S Ranch in Corning. The couple travels all over the West about 12 weeks out of the year conducting hackamore horse training clinics as well as producing training videos and DVDs with their Circle S Productions. “It’s the way that the old vaquero rode 260 years ago,” said Smith in a phone interview from Descanso where he was giving a presentation during Vaquero Days. The hackamore is a bit-less bridle that includes the hanger, bosal and macate, a 22-foot-long horse-hair rope....
Georgia dairy farmer wins world all-around title Dairy cows don't wait. Not even for world all-around champions. Ryan Jarrett, of Summerville, Ga., runs a 750-acre dairy farm with his father DeJuan in northwest Georgia. The cows will still need tending when Jarrett returns from the National Finals Rodeo. “I can't wait,” said the younger Jarrett of returning home. While the work for the cows remains the same, Jarrett does not. He returns to the farm as the 2005 PRCA world all-around champion. He is the first cowboy from Georgia - and the first from east of the Mississippi River - to win professional rodeo's most prestigious title. Jarrett, who turns 22 on Dec. 28, earned a total of $263,664 for the year in steer wrestling, tie-down roping and as a team roping header. He won $114,717 at the 10-performance National Finals Rodeo that concluded Sunday afternoon. Jarrett was the only two-event qualifier, competing in both steer wrestling and tie-down roping....
Wills Point bull rider wins with record haul Bull rider Matt Austin exceeded even his dreams. Austin, from Wills Point, Texas, said his goal this year was to win the world championship. Well, he accomplished that two days ago before the Wrangler National Finals Rodeo was completed. On Sunday, after riding Razor Sharp out of the Growney Brothers Rodeo for 88.5 points, he scaled another plateau. He finished second in the round and earned the aggregate title to become the all-time one-year earnings leader in pro rodeo, finishing the year with $320,765. That broke Ty Murray's mark of $297,896 in three events in 1983. Austin's record came in only one event, and he's the first cowboy to cross the $300,000 mark in one year. Austin joined four other Texans in the winners circle at the Thomas & Mack Center, with Fred Whitfield of Hockley winning his eighth tie-down roping title, Will Lowe of Canyon and Kelly Kaminski of Bellville winning their second championships in bareback riding and barrel racing, respectively, and Patrick Smith of Midland earning his first world heeling title....
It's All Trew: Problems build character for young I looked back into my early life for a comparable experience. The closest I could come was solving problems associated with building a slingshot. The materials were wood, rubber strips for power, strong twine and a small piece of flexible leather. Simple enough until you got into the technological problems. The first problem came in selecting the proper wood. An old dry tree fork was simple and easy to find. A green fork would be stronger but required some cutting and peeling. Next came the rubber strips. Was red or black rubber the best? Did you cut the strips longwise or crosswise from the inner-tube? Determining the proper length of the rubber strips was probably the most difficult problem I had encountered in my young life. I was always forced to use whatever materials were available, often eliminating the choice problem. Of great importance was the quality, flexibility and strength of the leather used to hold the rock or, as it would be called today, the "missile." Whatever you did, you didn't cut the tongue out of your father's Sunday shoes!! Though perfect in form and flexibility, it just wasn't worth it. I can testify to this from experience....
Monday, December 12, 2005
GAO REPORTS
Electronic Waste: Strengthening the Role of the Federal Government in Encouraging Recycling and Reuse. GAO-06-47, November 10.
http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-06-47
Highlights - http://www.gao.gov/highlights/d0647high.pdf
Livestock Market Reporting: USDA Has Taken Some Steps to Ensure Quality, but Additional Efforts Are Needed. GAO-06-202, December 9.
http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-06-202
Highlights - http://www.gao.gov/highlights/d06202high.pdf
Electronic Waste: Strengthening the Role of the Federal Government in Encouraging Recycling and Reuse. GAO-06-47, November 10.
http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-06-47
Highlights - http://www.gao.gov/highlights/d0647high.pdf
Livestock Market Reporting: USDA Has Taken Some Steps to Ensure Quality, but Additional Efforts Are Needed. GAO-06-202, December 9.
http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-06-202
Highlights - http://www.gao.gov/highlights/d06202high.pdf
NEWS ROUNDUP
Landowner near Rocky Flats sues to keep water and access rights A landowner near Rocky Flats filed suit against the government on Friday, asking the court to prevent the Department of Energy from cutting off water supplies and access to his mining and ranching operations. Charles Church McKay, a fourth-generation rancher in Jefferson County, is suing in U.S. District Court to enforce a 1985 settlement agreement involving the government's operation of the nuclear facility -- which has since been demolished. According to the agreement, the DOE would supply up to 20,000 gallons of water per day from its water treatment facility at Rocky Flats to the Rock Creek Industrial Park, on which McKay owns property that he would like to develop. The government and its contractors, including Rockwell International and Kaiser-Hill Co., have complied with the agreement for the last two decades, but stopped in the last year as they vacated the buildings, the lawsuit states. Mike Waldron, a spokesman for the DOE, declined to comment....
Valles Caldera Nat'l Preserve: From water to elks, lead scientist coordinating projects Bob Parmenter, the Valles Caldera National Preserve's lead scientist, stripped off his socks and boots on a blustery fall day recently and stepped bare footed into the freezing waters of a stream to retrieve a water-quality monitor. The easy-going ecologist collected samples at several more sites on the preserve (wearing wading boots) during the day and data from a group of soil scientists on another stop. "I like data. Data is good," said Parmenter, former director of the Sevilleta National Wildlife Refuge, who became the science manager at the preserve two and a half years ago. Parmenter oversees some two dozen research projects on the preserve including aerial mapping of vegetation, a radio-collaring project to find out if coyotes are responsible for fewer elk calves on the preserve and a study of how forage fairs without elk and cattle grazing. In addition, he monitors six weather stations, soil sampling, wildlife surveys and the aftermath of a 1,800 acre prescribed burn in Valle Toledo this fall....
Valles Caldera: Struggling to preserve When the Molina Complex Fire swept through part of the Santa Fe National Forest in 2003, it wiped out two-thirds of a grazing allotment leased by Pojoaque rancher David Ortiz. While the land recovered, Ortiz applied to graze his cattle on the Valles Caldera, an 89,000-acre ranch in Northern New Mexico purchased by the U.S. Congress in 2000. The preserve's grazing program has kept Ortiz's small herd fed, but the program is set to expire this month, and the trust that manages the Valles Caldera is considering closing the program for a year. "I'm hopeful they'll extend it," Ortiz said. "If not, I'll have to apply for a different allotment, find new summer pasture or sell and get out of the ranching business." Last year, 37 local ranchers and the Jemez Pueblo Livestock Cooperative participated in interim programs that provided them with summer grazing lands or temporary pasture while they worked on improving their own range. But grazing is a money loser. The program costs more than $100,000 and brought in about $40,000 last year, according to preserve figures. The future is uncertain for the former Baca ranch, six years after Congress agreed to pay $101 million....Ain't it amazing. Ranchers all over this country make money raising cows. Every gov't run grazing program, though, seems to lose money. 'Course I don't think there are too many cow men out there in the private sector doing "aerial mapping of vegetation"....
Methane boom takes toll in dust Outside the window of Jack Cooper's saddle shop in rural Sheridan County, there is nothing obstructing his scenic view of the jagged Bighorn Mountains that dominate the western horizon or the tree-lined creek winding its way through a wide valley to the east. Only the dust billowing from behind a constant procession of trucks heading to and from a nearby coalbed methane gas field gets in the way. Cooper lives along a gravel road that has become a major artery for trucks and workers in one of the many methane fields in northeast Wyoming. Traffic passing outside his home has increased from perhaps 75 to 100 vehicles a day just five years ago to 800 a day last year, he said. Dust hangs in the air like ground fog among the trees and rolling hills. "We don't dare leave a window open in the daytime," Cooper said. While oil and gas development creates other problems - housing shortages, noise, water pollution and increased crime - dust is just about universal in the booming methane fields of Wyoming and other states rich in natural gas....
'Clinton's monument' threatens nearby ranchers The second confrontation with CMR occurred when a "federal ranger" challenged Dave Collins and his crew moving cattle down a county road (established by order of the county commissioners and is continually maintained by them) from one of Mr. Collins' pastures to another pasture which happens to cross a section of the CMR. Mr. Collins maintained that "we never left the road right of way." He subsequently received a letter from the federal U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service administrator (they manage the CMR) stating that he would be required to obtain prior written permission each time he trailed cattle down that road. We are talking about a maintained county road which has a steady stream of cars and trucks usage on a regular basis. (The federal government certainly has the option to fence the right-of-way.) States, not the federal government, regulate public road usage and this example of federal government abuse of fundamental states' rights is very disturbing....
Rookie Senator Proving Green Some people are beginning to suspect Martinez is more green than they had thought, especially back in March when he cast the deciding Senate vote in favor of opening the Alaska National Wildlife Refuge to drilling. At the time, Sierra Club President Carl Pope accused Martinez of "selling out the country" and making it clear "he's for sale." Now, national environmental groups are heartened by his positions on other issues. "On most of the things I've followed, I've been pleased," said Frank Jackalone of St. Petersburg, Sierra Club senior regional representative for Florida and Puerto Rico. "The big exception is Arctic drilling. If he supports El Yunque, that's an important treasure to be preserved and I can do nothing but commend him. "When somebody goes the extra mile to actually go there and help protect it, you have to give him a plus on that." Martinez opposes oil and gas drilling in the eastern Gulf of Mexico, despite White House wishes. He even argued against a compromise advanced by Gov. Jeb Bush. He has in recent months championed a variety of causes, from barrier islands to coral reefs....
Forest joins shift away from old growth Southwest Oregon's Rogue River-Siskiyou National Forest has become the latest national forest to turn away from cutting storied old-growth trees, moving instead toward less-controversial thinning of crowded younger stands. The move reflects a broader trend by the U.S. Forest Service to give up logging of big, old trees that yield large volumes of valuable wood but have been a rallying cry for forest defenders. They have used appeals and lawsuits to fight the logging, driving up costs to the government. Other national forests including the Siuslaw, Gifford Pinchot and, increasingly, the Mount Hood, are no longer offering old-growth trees for sale to timber companies. Controversy surrounding such cutting often drains funds and leads to such interminable holdups that the projects may never proceed....
Outgoing interior assistant reflects on controversial times The urbanization of America has helped polarize beliefs about the environment, leaving many city dwellers with romanticized and often unrealistic views about wildlife and natural resources in the West, according to an outgoing federal executive who oversaw hundreds of millions of acres of public land. Rebecca W. Watson, who resigned earlier this month as an assistant secretary of the interior to take a job with a Denver law firm, said her four years at the Interior Department exposed her to a growing number of Easterners and others who apply "false perspectives" to conflicts over federal land management. "If you are an urbanite and don't have any familiarity or have not been out in the West or read about issues and gained a deeper understanding about natural resources and the West, you might have some ideas about it that don't hold up to reality," Watson said in a recent interview....
New turf for science: suburbia Suburbia may be familiar turf, but it's one of the last frontiers for scientists trying to understand how ecosystems work and how people are changing the natural world. From the woodsy suburban enclaves of Vermont to sprawling Chico, Livermore and Gilroy, researchers are starting to probe the role of lawns in global warming, how garden fertilizers and pesticides affect wildlife and how storm water running from roofs, roads and driveways undermines the health of streams. "The suburban landscape is large, and it's growing," said Jennifer Jenkins of the University of Vermont, one of the scientists who reported her findings last week at a meeting of the American Geophysical Union in San Francisco. "There's this enormous land surface that's falling through the cracks."....
Political foes' trails merge in forest Reps. Greg Walden and Earl Blumenauer come from different sides of Mount Hood, the snowcapped icon that looms over Portland and the Columbia Gorge. Walden, a Republican, comes from the rural conservative side that has traditionally viewed the forests on the mountain's flanks as a source of timber and jobs. Democrat Blumenauer comes from the urban, liberal side that depends on the mountain for drinking water and outdoor recreation. Despite past clashes over environmental issues, the two have come together, even buddying up for a backpacking trip around the mountain. Out of that has come a proposed bill to put 75,000 acres of wilderness off-limits to logging on the Mount Hood National Forest, without reducing the area where logging can occur....
Forest Service's logging plan rejected A federal appeals court has ruled against the U.S. Forest Service in a lawsuit over a logging proposal in the Lolo National Forest, calling the agency's decision to harvest timber in areas that were burned by the fires of 2000 "arbitrary and capricious." The decision reverses a 2003 ruling by U.S. District Judge Donald Molloy. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals likened the Forest Service's efforts to thin old-growth stands for forest health without knowing how those efforts would affect wildlife to pharmaceutical companies marketing drugs without ensuring that they're safe and effective. But one justice asserted in a written dissent that the court had gone too far and had "crossed the line from reviewer to decision maker." At issue is a debate over a portion of the 74,000 acres burned on the Lolo National Forest in August and September of 2000. The Forest Service proposed to log about 4,600 acres in and around the burned area. In support of that proposal, the agency crafted a 1,900-page environmental impact statement that included 150 maps and about 20,000 pages of background information....
Editorial: Lost in the wilderness The legendary U.S. Sen. Mark Hatfield regularly chose his re-election year to push through wilderness legislation protecting Oregon forests, mountains and rangelands for perpetuity. Hatfield understood the power and public appeal of wilderness. During his remarkable 30-year career in the Senate, he fought for legislation that not only created the Mount Jefferson Wilderness but also quadrupled Oregon's wilderness system, from 500,000 acres to 2.1 million acres. Oregon needs another strong, statewide advocate for wilderness protections. Oregon is far behind neighboring states in protecting wilderness: California has protected 13 percent of its landscape, Washington 10 percent and Oregon just 3.6 percent. Some lawmakers are trying: Reps. Greg Walden and Earl Blumenauer are co-sponsoring a bipartisan proposal to add 75,000 acres to existing Mount Hood wilderness. Sen. Ron Wyden has proposed a more sweeping 177,000-acre expansion of Mount Hood wilderness....
Future of timber payments to rural counties in doubt Rural counties and schools across the West are quietly gearing up for an expected battle over the renewal of billions of dollars in subsidies from the federal government, designed to compensate for the loss of timber harvests on thousands of acres of publicly owned land. The program, pushed through Congress in 2000 by Oregon Democratic Sen. Ron Wyden and Republican Sen. Larry Craig of Idaho, expires in 2006, and signals about its future from Washington, D.C., have been mixed. County commissioners and education officials in the rural West were already concerned about potentially wavering support from the Bush administration. Now, new concerns are surfacing that the bill might fall prey to those trolling for ways to pare the federal budget, as legislators search for a way to afford administration-backed tax cuts, the costs of rebuilding the Gulf Coast after Hurricanes Katrina and Rita and the war in Iraq, all at once. The measure has provided nearly $2 billion to mainly Western states since 2000, including $273 million for Oregon, $67 million for California, $45 million for Washington and $24 million to Idaho....
Surprise end to Sabino lion story Sabino Canyon's problem mountain lions, spared from state-ordered death in the spring of 2004, may have all been legally hunted and killed since then. At least four mountain lions have been shot in the Santa Catalina District of the Coronado National Forest since public uproar over state plans to hunt problem cats in Sabino Canyon in March 2004 caused the Arizona Game and Fish Commission to switch to a strategy of trapping and transporting such lions. One lion was tranquilized and moved to a Scottsdale wildlife preserve that April. Late this week, a wildlife biologist for the district revealed, in court testimony, that "archery deer hunters had taken two lions out of the Sabino Canyon area" since that time. And, as previously reported, two of the believed problem lions were taken in shotgun shootings by wildlife officers after the cats had confronted hikers on popular trails in the Santa Catalina Mountains in May and November 2004. Wildlife biologist Josh Taiz testified Thursday during the trial of two men charged with trying to disrupt the capture of lions in March 2004. Taiz, whose investigations of "aberrant behavior" by lions in the vicinity led to the 2004 Sabino Canyon closure and hunt, said the fact that lions could be taken by bowhunters reinforced his feeling that they had lost their usual fear of humans....
Reporter's tapes place activists in Sabino A reporter's notes were used in U.S. District Court Friday to place Earth First activists Rodney Coronado and Matthew Crozier in Sabino Canyon and detail their movements during a 2004 mountain-lion hunt they are accused of disrupting.
The notes were in the form of cassette tapes that Esquire magazine writer-at-large John Richardson dictated to himself. Coronado, 39, and Crozier, 33, are charged with a felony count of conspiracy to impede or injure an officer of the United States and misdemeanor counts of interfering with a U.S. Forest Service officer and depredation of government property. Richardson, the third defendant in the case, will be tried later, but his recordings, seized when Forest Service and FBI agents took him into custody in a closed Sabino Canyon on March 24, 2004, were played Friday to the jury that will decide Crozier's and Coronado's fates....
Fish protection charges up electricity bills Wildlife programs, mostly salmon recovery, account for about a third of the cost of wholesale electricity from Bonneville Power Administration dams and tack on about $10 a month to a monthly household bill, the BPA says. The agency says the government spends more to offset the harm dams do to salmon than it does on running the dams. But fish or no fish, BPA power is cheaper than most electricity. “Dams don’t cost much except for what they do to fish,’’ said Steven Weiss of the Northwest Energy Coalition, a coalition of environmental groups, utilities and others that pushes for renewable energy, and fish and wildlife restoration. The per-household cost emerged from a court battle last month and is the first time federal agencies have calculated how much private households pay for such programs, said Ed Mosey, a BPA spokesman. Environmental groups calculate the household cost slightly lower — about $7 a month, Weiss said....
California rabbits championed A canvas sack was rolled back to reveal a tiny, quivering rabbit that blinked twice in the daylight, then bolted into a tangle of blackberry bushes. "It's like being plunked down in a big city you've never seen before," said wildlife biologist Laurissa Hamilton as she released the riparian brush rabbit into dense vegetation alongside the San Joaquin River. The 1-pound animal was one of seven released Friday on the privately owned Faith Ranch as part of a five year, $2.6 million effort to restore one of California's most endangered mammals. By the end of this week, researchers will have released 30 animals -- enough to start a population specialists hope will become self-sustaining and help the rabbit hop off federal and state endangered species lists....
Greater Yellowstone; A Grizzly Home About 10 years ago a grizzly sow and her three cubs were seen by Paul Bruin as he was fishing the Snake just above Deadman's Bar in Grand Teton National Park. The following day these bears were tranquilized on South Park Loop at the Bob Lucas’s Ranch. She either skirted Jackson or walked straight down the river through the property of many unsuspecting homeowner. In November 2003 a 2-year-old female grizzly had been sleeping on people's porches and in garages for nearly a week in Driggs. 06-2004 JHMR ski patroller Kirk Speckhals was mountain biking on Togwotee Pass when a grizzly attacked him, it was driven off with pepper spray thanks to fellow mountain biker Tom Foley. Between 1994 and 1996, 182 cattle were found dead on 2 grazing allotments in Togwotee Pass. 3.5 calves are lost to grizzly depredation for every confirmed calf kill. These ranchers gave up their grazing allotment that made their ranch a viable business. They likely now regret getting involved with the Nature Conservancy in a partnership that preserved their ranch for green space and ranching negating their option to subdivide after losing their ability to ranch....
Editorial: Laws needed to protect private property rights Your land is not your own, particularly if government wants it. If you weren’t sure of that before, the latest sign comes from Yolo County, Calif., Superior Court Judge Timothy Fall, who made it clear to all that the threat of a government body taking land by eminent domain hangs like a dark cloud over all property owners. The decision clears the way for Yolo County to force the owners of Conaway Ranch to sell their property to the county. The irony of this dispute is that the county does not need the land for some compelling project to benefit the public like a new dam and reservoir to increase the state’s water supply or even an airport or an interstate freeway. No, the county wants the land to maintain it as it is. County officials are afraid of what the current property owners might do with the land so they decided to appropriate it. The Conaway Ranch case follows in the footsteps of the June U.S. Supreme Court case, Kelo v. City of New London, in which the court ruled that the city of New London, Conn., could use eminent domain to acquire property for a private economic development. However, the Conaway Ranch case goes beyond that. If Fall’s decision stands, it now appears local governments can take land just because they don’t trust the owners to use it in the manner government deems appropriate....
Utah drags its feet on roadless forests As surrounding states have scrambled during the past six months to meet a Forest Service deadline to identify roadless forest areas they wish to remain protected, Utah has done comparatively little. That is beginning to change. Gov. Jon M. Huntsman Jr. now is asking for recommendations from the counties, the start of what could become a formal process. But to what end remains to be seen. And whatever the result, it is unlikely to satisfy environmental critics. The Bush Administration repealed the Clinton-era Roadless Rule in May, which extended protection to nearly 59 million acres of pristine and largely remote forest lands. But as part of the policy change, the Agriculture Department created a process whereby governors can petition to keep roadless protections in their states intact. The petitions are due next November. Colorado's legislature has created a task force to study the issue and make recommendations. Montana's governor has traversed the state, holding public meetings in affected counties to gain input from politicians and the public alike. And California, Oregon and New Mexico have filed suit against the federal government over the roadless change, arguing that the Bush policy violates environmental laws and creates an undue burden on the states. By contrast, Huntsman has been content to let the Forest Service planning process determine the best use for Utah's 8.1 million acres of forest lands, about 4 million of which was designated as roadless....
New drilling hot spot triggers wildlife concerns As the snows pile up in the mountains, thousands of mule deer climb down from the higher elevations to winter on a sagebrush-strewn mesa. This tableland also is part of one of the largest gas fields in the country, the hot Pinedale Anticline Field. Federal regulators have given energy companies the green light to drill hundreds of wells in this field. And the Bush administration has agreed to allow producers to test restrictions that had barred drilling during the winter months, touching off a debate over whether the industry's hunt for gas is hampering wildlife's struggle to survive the harsh Wyoming winter....
Energy companies swarm the Rockies Oil and gas producers are stampeding to the Rockies. With natural gas prices hitting all-time highs and Gulf of Mexico production still recovering from a hurricane-plagued year, energy companies — many with ties to Houston — are drilling up long-neglected fields. The Rockies are thought to hold enough gas to heat and cool 70 million homes for nearly half a century, the National Petroleum Council estimates. But those resources are usually found in hard-to-produce deposits. In their headlong rush, the energy companies are helping transform the nation's least populous state, where pronghorn antelope are said to still outnumber people. Up and down Wyoming, oil-field service workers are packing hotels, not to mention Applebee's restaurants. They're driving up local real estate prices and bedding down in spartan — and that means booze-free — living quarters dubbed "man camps."....
Bush signs Grijalva bill to give back land to tribes For the people of the Colorado River Indian Tribes, whose reservation is 189 miles west of Phoenix, the return of their ancestral La Paz lands would be celebrated with a dedication of blessings, speeches and dances at a remote desert site. For Rep. Raul Grijalva, a two-term Democrat from Tucson, the first celebration came three weeks earlier when his bill to restore the land was signed into law by President Bush. Grijalva had worked for two years to give back 15,375 acres taken in 1915 by President Wilson. The late Sen. Barry Goldwater had twice attempted and failed to get the land returned....
Golden Gate national park to expand The U.S. House of Representatives on Tuesday approved adding nearly 5,000 acres of scenic land along the San Mateo County coast to the Golden Gate National Recreation Area, the largest expansion of that national park unit since it was established by Congress in 1972. The expansion includes Rancho Corral de Tierra, a sprawling, mountainous property that extends eastward across from the Half Moon Bay airport and surrounds the coastal towns of Moss Beach and Montara. The bill, which passed the Senate in July and is expected to be signed by President Bush, ends a four-year effort by environmentalists....
Plan would give island to military Santa Rosa Island in Channel Islands National Park off the coast of Southern California would become a recreation enclave for the military under a proposal for a pending defense bill. The measure was being circulated by Republican aides for the House Armed Services Committee, chaired by California GOP Rep. Duncan Hunter, according to Democratic congressional aides who made it public Friday. Hunter proposed a similar measure in May only to drop it amid objections from Democrats and environmentalists. His committee spokesman, Josh Holly, declined comment Friday. "This is a bad idea and that's why it's being pushed in secret negotiations behind closed doors and out of public view," said Rep. Lois Capps, D-Santa Barbara, whose district includes 53,000-acre Santa Rosa Island off Santa Barbara. "All Americans should have access to the Channel Islands National Park, not just top military brass, members of Congress and folks who can pay thousands of dollars to go on private hunting trips," Capps said....
Las Vegas boom deals some a losing hand At first glance, Las Vegas has never had it so good. In fact, this desert valley of almost 2 million people is the fastest-growing in the country. Las Vegas, in fact, leads the nation in job creation, and it has a white-hot housing market. ''It's going phenomenally well," said Mayor Oscar Goodman, a former lawyer for mobsters. But as bright as the present appears, there are signs that Las Vegas is becoming polarized. Prices have pushed home purchases beyond the reach of many families. Crime is on the rise. And activists report problems in recruiting teachers, nurses, and police to serve a population growing by 6,000 a month....
‘Mad cow’ changes global cattle industry For ranchers like Bill Donald, the resumption of beef trade with Japan, two years after "mad cow disease" turned up in this country, would be huge. Still, he’s not ready to sell his own cattle to Japan, and he’s not alone. ‘‘I think most ranchers won’t bother with it this first year,’’ the south- central Montana rancher said. ‘‘There are a lot of hoops to jump through.’’ New requirements for doing business in Japan could keep many producers from tapping that once-lucrative market — at least initially. Selling beef to Japan will mean maintaining a paper trail from the ranch to the feedlot to the slaughterhouse, to verify cattle are killed at 20 months of age or younger. The levels of infection for mad cow disease are believed to rise with age, and plans for resuming trade have been based on that cutoff....
A Kansas shrine for Hopalong His was a face that had seen too much in this life to be easily impressed with trivia or knickknacks. As others chattered happily through the museum tour, he smiled politely but remained detached. And then it happened. The one exhibit that made his face light up like a Christmas tree. Indeed it was a Christmas tree, and surrounding it were hundreds of gifts, all appropriate for a child of the early 1950s. But his eyes zeroed in on the bicycle--a shiny black 20-inch Hoppy bike, complete with leather saddlebags and streamers. "I wanted one of those so bad when I was a kid," he nearly shouted, drawing the attention of not only his companions, but others visiting the museum. The bicycle is one of 2,400 signature items on display at the Hopalong Cassidy Museum in this town about 15 miles north of Wichita. Since its opening in 2003, more than 70,000 children of the 1950s have relived the jubilation of their childhood Christmas mornings, similar to the unidentified man above. Billed as the largest collection of Hopalong Cassidy items in the world, the museum does more than celebrate the beloved radio, television and movie character (played by William Boyd in 66 feature-length movies, beginning in 1935, and 52 half-hour TV shows that aired on NBC from 1948 through 1952). It celebrates the American cowboy with exhibits devoted to the Chisholm Trail, to Roy Rogers and Dale Evans, Gene Autry and the American Indian....
Jones Down Home in Texas Tommy Lee Jones doesn’t work just for the sake of working. He tries to choose only quality jobs. He says he turns down a lot of films because simply “they aren't any good.” But while Jones has become a Hollywood star, he's always been uncomfortable with the Hollywood spotlight. “Here, on this ranch and in this county, everybody knows everybody and we don't have any movie stars here,” says the notoriously private and sometimes a bit prickly actor of his sprawling ranch in the Texas hill country. He's also a hands-on rancher with a commercial cattle operation....
On the Edge of Common Sense: Buyers experience auction barn miracle If ya hang around a sale barn long enough, you are bound to see some strange, some would say supernatural or even extraterrestrial, happenings. Like a cattle buyer actually bidding a penny over the market, or a waiter in a tuxedo at the sale barn cafe, or what happened to Chato and the Indian cow. Sonny said when the truck arrived from the reservation, a lot of the cows were thin but the last one required gentle assistance to unload. She was a common lookin' white face cow with a wide muzzle, ringed horns, bony hips and a long tail. A T-11 brand as well as several hieroglyphic brands decorated her hide. Chato came in to report that the cow in question was now, and as he put it, "had been dead all day long!" Sonny sent two cowboys to the pen. Sure 'nuf, she was still dead....
Landowner near Rocky Flats sues to keep water and access rights A landowner near Rocky Flats filed suit against the government on Friday, asking the court to prevent the Department of Energy from cutting off water supplies and access to his mining and ranching operations. Charles Church McKay, a fourth-generation rancher in Jefferson County, is suing in U.S. District Court to enforce a 1985 settlement agreement involving the government's operation of the nuclear facility -- which has since been demolished. According to the agreement, the DOE would supply up to 20,000 gallons of water per day from its water treatment facility at Rocky Flats to the Rock Creek Industrial Park, on which McKay owns property that he would like to develop. The government and its contractors, including Rockwell International and Kaiser-Hill Co., have complied with the agreement for the last two decades, but stopped in the last year as they vacated the buildings, the lawsuit states. Mike Waldron, a spokesman for the DOE, declined to comment....
Valles Caldera Nat'l Preserve: From water to elks, lead scientist coordinating projects Bob Parmenter, the Valles Caldera National Preserve's lead scientist, stripped off his socks and boots on a blustery fall day recently and stepped bare footed into the freezing waters of a stream to retrieve a water-quality monitor. The easy-going ecologist collected samples at several more sites on the preserve (wearing wading boots) during the day and data from a group of soil scientists on another stop. "I like data. Data is good," said Parmenter, former director of the Sevilleta National Wildlife Refuge, who became the science manager at the preserve two and a half years ago. Parmenter oversees some two dozen research projects on the preserve including aerial mapping of vegetation, a radio-collaring project to find out if coyotes are responsible for fewer elk calves on the preserve and a study of how forage fairs without elk and cattle grazing. In addition, he monitors six weather stations, soil sampling, wildlife surveys and the aftermath of a 1,800 acre prescribed burn in Valle Toledo this fall....
Valles Caldera: Struggling to preserve When the Molina Complex Fire swept through part of the Santa Fe National Forest in 2003, it wiped out two-thirds of a grazing allotment leased by Pojoaque rancher David Ortiz. While the land recovered, Ortiz applied to graze his cattle on the Valles Caldera, an 89,000-acre ranch in Northern New Mexico purchased by the U.S. Congress in 2000. The preserve's grazing program has kept Ortiz's small herd fed, but the program is set to expire this month, and the trust that manages the Valles Caldera is considering closing the program for a year. "I'm hopeful they'll extend it," Ortiz said. "If not, I'll have to apply for a different allotment, find new summer pasture or sell and get out of the ranching business." Last year, 37 local ranchers and the Jemez Pueblo Livestock Cooperative participated in interim programs that provided them with summer grazing lands or temporary pasture while they worked on improving their own range. But grazing is a money loser. The program costs more than $100,000 and brought in about $40,000 last year, according to preserve figures. The future is uncertain for the former Baca ranch, six years after Congress agreed to pay $101 million....Ain't it amazing. Ranchers all over this country make money raising cows. Every gov't run grazing program, though, seems to lose money. 'Course I don't think there are too many cow men out there in the private sector doing "aerial mapping of vegetation"....
Methane boom takes toll in dust Outside the window of Jack Cooper's saddle shop in rural Sheridan County, there is nothing obstructing his scenic view of the jagged Bighorn Mountains that dominate the western horizon or the tree-lined creek winding its way through a wide valley to the east. Only the dust billowing from behind a constant procession of trucks heading to and from a nearby coalbed methane gas field gets in the way. Cooper lives along a gravel road that has become a major artery for trucks and workers in one of the many methane fields in northeast Wyoming. Traffic passing outside his home has increased from perhaps 75 to 100 vehicles a day just five years ago to 800 a day last year, he said. Dust hangs in the air like ground fog among the trees and rolling hills. "We don't dare leave a window open in the daytime," Cooper said. While oil and gas development creates other problems - housing shortages, noise, water pollution and increased crime - dust is just about universal in the booming methane fields of Wyoming and other states rich in natural gas....
'Clinton's monument' threatens nearby ranchers The second confrontation with CMR occurred when a "federal ranger" challenged Dave Collins and his crew moving cattle down a county road (established by order of the county commissioners and is continually maintained by them) from one of Mr. Collins' pastures to another pasture which happens to cross a section of the CMR. Mr. Collins maintained that "we never left the road right of way." He subsequently received a letter from the federal U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service administrator (they manage the CMR) stating that he would be required to obtain prior written permission each time he trailed cattle down that road. We are talking about a maintained county road which has a steady stream of cars and trucks usage on a regular basis. (The federal government certainly has the option to fence the right-of-way.) States, not the federal government, regulate public road usage and this example of federal government abuse of fundamental states' rights is very disturbing....
Rookie Senator Proving Green Some people are beginning to suspect Martinez is more green than they had thought, especially back in March when he cast the deciding Senate vote in favor of opening the Alaska National Wildlife Refuge to drilling. At the time, Sierra Club President Carl Pope accused Martinez of "selling out the country" and making it clear "he's for sale." Now, national environmental groups are heartened by his positions on other issues. "On most of the things I've followed, I've been pleased," said Frank Jackalone of St. Petersburg, Sierra Club senior regional representative for Florida and Puerto Rico. "The big exception is Arctic drilling. If he supports El Yunque, that's an important treasure to be preserved and I can do nothing but commend him. "When somebody goes the extra mile to actually go there and help protect it, you have to give him a plus on that." Martinez opposes oil and gas drilling in the eastern Gulf of Mexico, despite White House wishes. He even argued against a compromise advanced by Gov. Jeb Bush. He has in recent months championed a variety of causes, from barrier islands to coral reefs....
Forest joins shift away from old growth Southwest Oregon's Rogue River-Siskiyou National Forest has become the latest national forest to turn away from cutting storied old-growth trees, moving instead toward less-controversial thinning of crowded younger stands. The move reflects a broader trend by the U.S. Forest Service to give up logging of big, old trees that yield large volumes of valuable wood but have been a rallying cry for forest defenders. They have used appeals and lawsuits to fight the logging, driving up costs to the government. Other national forests including the Siuslaw, Gifford Pinchot and, increasingly, the Mount Hood, are no longer offering old-growth trees for sale to timber companies. Controversy surrounding such cutting often drains funds and leads to such interminable holdups that the projects may never proceed....
Outgoing interior assistant reflects on controversial times The urbanization of America has helped polarize beliefs about the environment, leaving many city dwellers with romanticized and often unrealistic views about wildlife and natural resources in the West, according to an outgoing federal executive who oversaw hundreds of millions of acres of public land. Rebecca W. Watson, who resigned earlier this month as an assistant secretary of the interior to take a job with a Denver law firm, said her four years at the Interior Department exposed her to a growing number of Easterners and others who apply "false perspectives" to conflicts over federal land management. "If you are an urbanite and don't have any familiarity or have not been out in the West or read about issues and gained a deeper understanding about natural resources and the West, you might have some ideas about it that don't hold up to reality," Watson said in a recent interview....
New turf for science: suburbia Suburbia may be familiar turf, but it's one of the last frontiers for scientists trying to understand how ecosystems work and how people are changing the natural world. From the woodsy suburban enclaves of Vermont to sprawling Chico, Livermore and Gilroy, researchers are starting to probe the role of lawns in global warming, how garden fertilizers and pesticides affect wildlife and how storm water running from roofs, roads and driveways undermines the health of streams. "The suburban landscape is large, and it's growing," said Jennifer Jenkins of the University of Vermont, one of the scientists who reported her findings last week at a meeting of the American Geophysical Union in San Francisco. "There's this enormous land surface that's falling through the cracks."....
Political foes' trails merge in forest Reps. Greg Walden and Earl Blumenauer come from different sides of Mount Hood, the snowcapped icon that looms over Portland and the Columbia Gorge. Walden, a Republican, comes from the rural conservative side that has traditionally viewed the forests on the mountain's flanks as a source of timber and jobs. Democrat Blumenauer comes from the urban, liberal side that depends on the mountain for drinking water and outdoor recreation. Despite past clashes over environmental issues, the two have come together, even buddying up for a backpacking trip around the mountain. Out of that has come a proposed bill to put 75,000 acres of wilderness off-limits to logging on the Mount Hood National Forest, without reducing the area where logging can occur....
Forest Service's logging plan rejected A federal appeals court has ruled against the U.S. Forest Service in a lawsuit over a logging proposal in the Lolo National Forest, calling the agency's decision to harvest timber in areas that were burned by the fires of 2000 "arbitrary and capricious." The decision reverses a 2003 ruling by U.S. District Judge Donald Molloy. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals likened the Forest Service's efforts to thin old-growth stands for forest health without knowing how those efforts would affect wildlife to pharmaceutical companies marketing drugs without ensuring that they're safe and effective. But one justice asserted in a written dissent that the court had gone too far and had "crossed the line from reviewer to decision maker." At issue is a debate over a portion of the 74,000 acres burned on the Lolo National Forest in August and September of 2000. The Forest Service proposed to log about 4,600 acres in and around the burned area. In support of that proposal, the agency crafted a 1,900-page environmental impact statement that included 150 maps and about 20,000 pages of background information....
Editorial: Lost in the wilderness The legendary U.S. Sen. Mark Hatfield regularly chose his re-election year to push through wilderness legislation protecting Oregon forests, mountains and rangelands for perpetuity. Hatfield understood the power and public appeal of wilderness. During his remarkable 30-year career in the Senate, he fought for legislation that not only created the Mount Jefferson Wilderness but also quadrupled Oregon's wilderness system, from 500,000 acres to 2.1 million acres. Oregon needs another strong, statewide advocate for wilderness protections. Oregon is far behind neighboring states in protecting wilderness: California has protected 13 percent of its landscape, Washington 10 percent and Oregon just 3.6 percent. Some lawmakers are trying: Reps. Greg Walden and Earl Blumenauer are co-sponsoring a bipartisan proposal to add 75,000 acres to existing Mount Hood wilderness. Sen. Ron Wyden has proposed a more sweeping 177,000-acre expansion of Mount Hood wilderness....
Future of timber payments to rural counties in doubt Rural counties and schools across the West are quietly gearing up for an expected battle over the renewal of billions of dollars in subsidies from the federal government, designed to compensate for the loss of timber harvests on thousands of acres of publicly owned land. The program, pushed through Congress in 2000 by Oregon Democratic Sen. Ron Wyden and Republican Sen. Larry Craig of Idaho, expires in 2006, and signals about its future from Washington, D.C., have been mixed. County commissioners and education officials in the rural West were already concerned about potentially wavering support from the Bush administration. Now, new concerns are surfacing that the bill might fall prey to those trolling for ways to pare the federal budget, as legislators search for a way to afford administration-backed tax cuts, the costs of rebuilding the Gulf Coast after Hurricanes Katrina and Rita and the war in Iraq, all at once. The measure has provided nearly $2 billion to mainly Western states since 2000, including $273 million for Oregon, $67 million for California, $45 million for Washington and $24 million to Idaho....
Surprise end to Sabino lion story Sabino Canyon's problem mountain lions, spared from state-ordered death in the spring of 2004, may have all been legally hunted and killed since then. At least four mountain lions have been shot in the Santa Catalina District of the Coronado National Forest since public uproar over state plans to hunt problem cats in Sabino Canyon in March 2004 caused the Arizona Game and Fish Commission to switch to a strategy of trapping and transporting such lions. One lion was tranquilized and moved to a Scottsdale wildlife preserve that April. Late this week, a wildlife biologist for the district revealed, in court testimony, that "archery deer hunters had taken two lions out of the Sabino Canyon area" since that time. And, as previously reported, two of the believed problem lions were taken in shotgun shootings by wildlife officers after the cats had confronted hikers on popular trails in the Santa Catalina Mountains in May and November 2004. Wildlife biologist Josh Taiz testified Thursday during the trial of two men charged with trying to disrupt the capture of lions in March 2004. Taiz, whose investigations of "aberrant behavior" by lions in the vicinity led to the 2004 Sabino Canyon closure and hunt, said the fact that lions could be taken by bowhunters reinforced his feeling that they had lost their usual fear of humans....
Reporter's tapes place activists in Sabino A reporter's notes were used in U.S. District Court Friday to place Earth First activists Rodney Coronado and Matthew Crozier in Sabino Canyon and detail their movements during a 2004 mountain-lion hunt they are accused of disrupting.
The notes were in the form of cassette tapes that Esquire magazine writer-at-large John Richardson dictated to himself. Coronado, 39, and Crozier, 33, are charged with a felony count of conspiracy to impede or injure an officer of the United States and misdemeanor counts of interfering with a U.S. Forest Service officer and depredation of government property. Richardson, the third defendant in the case, will be tried later, but his recordings, seized when Forest Service and FBI agents took him into custody in a closed Sabino Canyon on March 24, 2004, were played Friday to the jury that will decide Crozier's and Coronado's fates....
Fish protection charges up electricity bills Wildlife programs, mostly salmon recovery, account for about a third of the cost of wholesale electricity from Bonneville Power Administration dams and tack on about $10 a month to a monthly household bill, the BPA says. The agency says the government spends more to offset the harm dams do to salmon than it does on running the dams. But fish or no fish, BPA power is cheaper than most electricity. “Dams don’t cost much except for what they do to fish,’’ said Steven Weiss of the Northwest Energy Coalition, a coalition of environmental groups, utilities and others that pushes for renewable energy, and fish and wildlife restoration. The per-household cost emerged from a court battle last month and is the first time federal agencies have calculated how much private households pay for such programs, said Ed Mosey, a BPA spokesman. Environmental groups calculate the household cost slightly lower — about $7 a month, Weiss said....
California rabbits championed A canvas sack was rolled back to reveal a tiny, quivering rabbit that blinked twice in the daylight, then bolted into a tangle of blackberry bushes. "It's like being plunked down in a big city you've never seen before," said wildlife biologist Laurissa Hamilton as she released the riparian brush rabbit into dense vegetation alongside the San Joaquin River. The 1-pound animal was one of seven released Friday on the privately owned Faith Ranch as part of a five year, $2.6 million effort to restore one of California's most endangered mammals. By the end of this week, researchers will have released 30 animals -- enough to start a population specialists hope will become self-sustaining and help the rabbit hop off federal and state endangered species lists....
Greater Yellowstone; A Grizzly Home About 10 years ago a grizzly sow and her three cubs were seen by Paul Bruin as he was fishing the Snake just above Deadman's Bar in Grand Teton National Park. The following day these bears were tranquilized on South Park Loop at the Bob Lucas’s Ranch. She either skirted Jackson or walked straight down the river through the property of many unsuspecting homeowner. In November 2003 a 2-year-old female grizzly had been sleeping on people's porches and in garages for nearly a week in Driggs. 06-2004 JHMR ski patroller Kirk Speckhals was mountain biking on Togwotee Pass when a grizzly attacked him, it was driven off with pepper spray thanks to fellow mountain biker Tom Foley. Between 1994 and 1996, 182 cattle were found dead on 2 grazing allotments in Togwotee Pass. 3.5 calves are lost to grizzly depredation for every confirmed calf kill. These ranchers gave up their grazing allotment that made their ranch a viable business. They likely now regret getting involved with the Nature Conservancy in a partnership that preserved their ranch for green space and ranching negating their option to subdivide after losing their ability to ranch....
Editorial: Laws needed to protect private property rights Your land is not your own, particularly if government wants it. If you weren’t sure of that before, the latest sign comes from Yolo County, Calif., Superior Court Judge Timothy Fall, who made it clear to all that the threat of a government body taking land by eminent domain hangs like a dark cloud over all property owners. The decision clears the way for Yolo County to force the owners of Conaway Ranch to sell their property to the county. The irony of this dispute is that the county does not need the land for some compelling project to benefit the public like a new dam and reservoir to increase the state’s water supply or even an airport or an interstate freeway. No, the county wants the land to maintain it as it is. County officials are afraid of what the current property owners might do with the land so they decided to appropriate it. The Conaway Ranch case follows in the footsteps of the June U.S. Supreme Court case, Kelo v. City of New London, in which the court ruled that the city of New London, Conn., could use eminent domain to acquire property for a private economic development. However, the Conaway Ranch case goes beyond that. If Fall’s decision stands, it now appears local governments can take land just because they don’t trust the owners to use it in the manner government deems appropriate....
Utah drags its feet on roadless forests As surrounding states have scrambled during the past six months to meet a Forest Service deadline to identify roadless forest areas they wish to remain protected, Utah has done comparatively little. That is beginning to change. Gov. Jon M. Huntsman Jr. now is asking for recommendations from the counties, the start of what could become a formal process. But to what end remains to be seen. And whatever the result, it is unlikely to satisfy environmental critics. The Bush Administration repealed the Clinton-era Roadless Rule in May, which extended protection to nearly 59 million acres of pristine and largely remote forest lands. But as part of the policy change, the Agriculture Department created a process whereby governors can petition to keep roadless protections in their states intact. The petitions are due next November. Colorado's legislature has created a task force to study the issue and make recommendations. Montana's governor has traversed the state, holding public meetings in affected counties to gain input from politicians and the public alike. And California, Oregon and New Mexico have filed suit against the federal government over the roadless change, arguing that the Bush policy violates environmental laws and creates an undue burden on the states. By contrast, Huntsman has been content to let the Forest Service planning process determine the best use for Utah's 8.1 million acres of forest lands, about 4 million of which was designated as roadless....
New drilling hot spot triggers wildlife concerns As the snows pile up in the mountains, thousands of mule deer climb down from the higher elevations to winter on a sagebrush-strewn mesa. This tableland also is part of one of the largest gas fields in the country, the hot Pinedale Anticline Field. Federal regulators have given energy companies the green light to drill hundreds of wells in this field. And the Bush administration has agreed to allow producers to test restrictions that had barred drilling during the winter months, touching off a debate over whether the industry's hunt for gas is hampering wildlife's struggle to survive the harsh Wyoming winter....
Energy companies swarm the Rockies Oil and gas producers are stampeding to the Rockies. With natural gas prices hitting all-time highs and Gulf of Mexico production still recovering from a hurricane-plagued year, energy companies — many with ties to Houston — are drilling up long-neglected fields. The Rockies are thought to hold enough gas to heat and cool 70 million homes for nearly half a century, the National Petroleum Council estimates. But those resources are usually found in hard-to-produce deposits. In their headlong rush, the energy companies are helping transform the nation's least populous state, where pronghorn antelope are said to still outnumber people. Up and down Wyoming, oil-field service workers are packing hotels, not to mention Applebee's restaurants. They're driving up local real estate prices and bedding down in spartan — and that means booze-free — living quarters dubbed "man camps."....
Bush signs Grijalva bill to give back land to tribes For the people of the Colorado River Indian Tribes, whose reservation is 189 miles west of Phoenix, the return of their ancestral La Paz lands would be celebrated with a dedication of blessings, speeches and dances at a remote desert site. For Rep. Raul Grijalva, a two-term Democrat from Tucson, the first celebration came three weeks earlier when his bill to restore the land was signed into law by President Bush. Grijalva had worked for two years to give back 15,375 acres taken in 1915 by President Wilson. The late Sen. Barry Goldwater had twice attempted and failed to get the land returned....
Golden Gate national park to expand The U.S. House of Representatives on Tuesday approved adding nearly 5,000 acres of scenic land along the San Mateo County coast to the Golden Gate National Recreation Area, the largest expansion of that national park unit since it was established by Congress in 1972. The expansion includes Rancho Corral de Tierra, a sprawling, mountainous property that extends eastward across from the Half Moon Bay airport and surrounds the coastal towns of Moss Beach and Montara. The bill, which passed the Senate in July and is expected to be signed by President Bush, ends a four-year effort by environmentalists....
Plan would give island to military Santa Rosa Island in Channel Islands National Park off the coast of Southern California would become a recreation enclave for the military under a proposal for a pending defense bill. The measure was being circulated by Republican aides for the House Armed Services Committee, chaired by California GOP Rep. Duncan Hunter, according to Democratic congressional aides who made it public Friday. Hunter proposed a similar measure in May only to drop it amid objections from Democrats and environmentalists. His committee spokesman, Josh Holly, declined comment Friday. "This is a bad idea and that's why it's being pushed in secret negotiations behind closed doors and out of public view," said Rep. Lois Capps, D-Santa Barbara, whose district includes 53,000-acre Santa Rosa Island off Santa Barbara. "All Americans should have access to the Channel Islands National Park, not just top military brass, members of Congress and folks who can pay thousands of dollars to go on private hunting trips," Capps said....
Las Vegas boom deals some a losing hand At first glance, Las Vegas has never had it so good. In fact, this desert valley of almost 2 million people is the fastest-growing in the country. Las Vegas, in fact, leads the nation in job creation, and it has a white-hot housing market. ''It's going phenomenally well," said Mayor Oscar Goodman, a former lawyer for mobsters. But as bright as the present appears, there are signs that Las Vegas is becoming polarized. Prices have pushed home purchases beyond the reach of many families. Crime is on the rise. And activists report problems in recruiting teachers, nurses, and police to serve a population growing by 6,000 a month....
‘Mad cow’ changes global cattle industry For ranchers like Bill Donald, the resumption of beef trade with Japan, two years after "mad cow disease" turned up in this country, would be huge. Still, he’s not ready to sell his own cattle to Japan, and he’s not alone. ‘‘I think most ranchers won’t bother with it this first year,’’ the south- central Montana rancher said. ‘‘There are a lot of hoops to jump through.’’ New requirements for doing business in Japan could keep many producers from tapping that once-lucrative market — at least initially. Selling beef to Japan will mean maintaining a paper trail from the ranch to the feedlot to the slaughterhouse, to verify cattle are killed at 20 months of age or younger. The levels of infection for mad cow disease are believed to rise with age, and plans for resuming trade have been based on that cutoff....
A Kansas shrine for Hopalong His was a face that had seen too much in this life to be easily impressed with trivia or knickknacks. As others chattered happily through the museum tour, he smiled politely but remained detached. And then it happened. The one exhibit that made his face light up like a Christmas tree. Indeed it was a Christmas tree, and surrounding it were hundreds of gifts, all appropriate for a child of the early 1950s. But his eyes zeroed in on the bicycle--a shiny black 20-inch Hoppy bike, complete with leather saddlebags and streamers. "I wanted one of those so bad when I was a kid," he nearly shouted, drawing the attention of not only his companions, but others visiting the museum. The bicycle is one of 2,400 signature items on display at the Hopalong Cassidy Museum in this town about 15 miles north of Wichita. Since its opening in 2003, more than 70,000 children of the 1950s have relived the jubilation of their childhood Christmas mornings, similar to the unidentified man above. Billed as the largest collection of Hopalong Cassidy items in the world, the museum does more than celebrate the beloved radio, television and movie character (played by William Boyd in 66 feature-length movies, beginning in 1935, and 52 half-hour TV shows that aired on NBC from 1948 through 1952). It celebrates the American cowboy with exhibits devoted to the Chisholm Trail, to Roy Rogers and Dale Evans, Gene Autry and the American Indian....
Jones Down Home in Texas Tommy Lee Jones doesn’t work just for the sake of working. He tries to choose only quality jobs. He says he turns down a lot of films because simply “they aren't any good.” But while Jones has become a Hollywood star, he's always been uncomfortable with the Hollywood spotlight. “Here, on this ranch and in this county, everybody knows everybody and we don't have any movie stars here,” says the notoriously private and sometimes a bit prickly actor of his sprawling ranch in the Texas hill country. He's also a hands-on rancher with a commercial cattle operation....
On the Edge of Common Sense: Buyers experience auction barn miracle If ya hang around a sale barn long enough, you are bound to see some strange, some would say supernatural or even extraterrestrial, happenings. Like a cattle buyer actually bidding a penny over the market, or a waiter in a tuxedo at the sale barn cafe, or what happened to Chato and the Indian cow. Sonny said when the truck arrived from the reservation, a lot of the cows were thin but the last one required gentle assistance to unload. She was a common lookin' white face cow with a wide muzzle, ringed horns, bony hips and a long tail. A T-11 brand as well as several hieroglyphic brands decorated her hide. Chato came in to report that the cow in question was now, and as he put it, "had been dead all day long!" Sonny sent two cowboys to the pen. Sure 'nuf, she was still dead....
Sunday, December 11, 2005
DANIEL MARTINEZ---USFS
Dear Editor:
County Attorney Derek Rapier and Sheriff Steve Tucker appear to be missing the point as to why people feel they should have been more involved in the Martinez Ranch dispute. To fully understand why citizens of Greenlee County are so puzzled as to their lack of action, it is important to first look at the broad picture.
There is a clear trend occurring on the forest lands from Clifton to Alpine. Cattle have been removed first from the river areas, now from the upland areas; roads are being closed at an alarming rate; and the Forest Service is acquiring most of the private land in the area. Years ago, environmental groups targeted these lands as an area they would like to use strictly for wildlife, with emphasis on introduction of wolves, grizzly bears, and jaguars into the area.
While they cannot accomplish these goals in one swipe, radical environmental groups feel they can methodically accomplish their goal by chipping away and gaining one piece of their ultimate goal at a time (closing of one road at a time, removing grazing from one allotment at a time, etc.). Actions from local Forest Service officials over the past decade indicate a willingness to help the environmental groups attain their objectives.
The Martinez family has ranched and paid taxes in Greenlee County for 160 years. They are award-winning stewards of the land and have spent thousands of their hard-earned dollars on range improvements that help wildlife as well as livestock. Their operation has historically been considered a model for good management. They have received letters from former Forest Service officials commending their good management. They are considered ranchers that have always “played by the rules”.
It is no secret that any time you decide to “take on” the federal government you are going to have your hands full. So why have the Martinez’s drawn a line in the sand with the Forest Service? First, they too understand that Greenlee County has been targeted for a large endangered species refuge and want to help reverse the disturbing trend.
Second, they believe the Forest Service should be able to transfer their grazing permit from father to son without infringing on their private rights. They have refused to sign the waiver that they believe would endorse a reduction in their permit as well as take away rights associated with their allotment. The Martinez family is not claiming that they own the land, only that they have private property (rights) associated with the land. They will pay grazing fees when presented with a bill.
So where should Greenlee County get involved in all of this? Arguments can be made for or against county intervention on the very complex issue of the property rights claims. The courts will ultimately answer the property rights questions arising from the Martinez claims.
However, the issue of impounding and selling the Martinez cattle, is another matter. I believe there are numerous actions our Sheriff and County Attorney could have and should have attempted in an effort to stop this negative fiasco from occurring. Let me explain:
1. The agreement between the Forest Service and the Arizona Department of Agriculture created a double standard for the impoundment of livestock; the agreement allows the Forest Service to sell the cattle without a court order. Yet, a court order is required for the Arizona State Land Department to impound and sell livestock on Arizona State lands; a court order is also required before a financial institution can gather and sell cattle from a ranch that has defaulted on a loan. Why then, should the Forest Service be allowed to gather and sell cattle without a court order?
Our government is a system of checks and balances. The question arises, “When the State decided to make a political decision on this issue, why didn’t the County Attorney and Sheriff challenge the validity of the agreement and subsequent impoundment?” After 160 years of being good citizens of this county has the Martinez family not earned at least that much?
All property owners live in some degree of fear that the Federal government will someday find a reason to take his or her property. It certainly does not seem unreasonable to require a court order for the confiscation and selling of private property. The Sheriff and County Attorney could have easily taken a stand on behalf of the property owners in Greenlee County and told the Forest Service that no cattle would be taken from this county without a court order.
2. It appears that the gathering and attempted sale of the Martinez cattle is intended to bring down one of Greenlee County’s cornerstone families and to permanently dismember their livestock operation. There were avenues available to the Forest Service to avoid the impoundment, but they chose not to utilize them. Some options include:
-Forest Service grazing permits have been transferred from one owner to another in other Forest Districts without signing a waiver. (I recently talked to a rancher who has done it).
-The Forest Service can also allow a permittee to let another rancher run cattle on his/her allotment. An agreement to let the son run cattle on the father’s ranch could have been an option. This has occurred on one of the neighboring allotments.
Did our elected leaders (Sheriff and County Attorney) ever tell the Forest Service they would like to try to find a way to avoid the impoundment?
3. While they were gathering the cattle, the Forest Service closed the Rattlesnake Gap road. This occurred during deer hunting season. Why was the road closed? Shouldn’t that action have been challenged on behalf of the citizens of Greenlee County?
4. The Forest Service hired armed federal law enforcement to protect Forest Service employees and the contractors hired to gather the cattle. Why? The Martinez family has no history of violence. Many citizens have pointed out how intimidating it is to have these armed federal employees in our community. Shouldn’t the Sheriff have challenged that action to avoid such an ugly scene in our county.
Because they have the most power to represent our interests, we look to our elected officials to stand up on our behalf and protect our rights. The impoundment of the Martinez cattle is probably the most negative event to occur in Greenlee County in decades and could likely have been avoided with minimal intervention from county elected officials.
Our Sheriff and County Attorney are our most powerful county elected officials in these matters. Citizens in this area understand that challenging the federal government is a tough task, and we know we’re not going to win every battle. Property owners do however, want to know that if the federal government finds a reason to take their property, our county officials will do everything they can to protect them. The current feeling is that the lack of action by our County Attorney and Sheriff is helping the Forest Service in their apparent attempt to bring down the Martinez family. Effort is all we are asking for, but to this point it really has not been there.
Jeff Menges
Local Rancher
Dear Editor:
County Attorney Derek Rapier and Sheriff Steve Tucker appear to be missing the point as to why people feel they should have been more involved in the Martinez Ranch dispute. To fully understand why citizens of Greenlee County are so puzzled as to their lack of action, it is important to first look at the broad picture.
There is a clear trend occurring on the forest lands from Clifton to Alpine. Cattle have been removed first from the river areas, now from the upland areas; roads are being closed at an alarming rate; and the Forest Service is acquiring most of the private land in the area. Years ago, environmental groups targeted these lands as an area they would like to use strictly for wildlife, with emphasis on introduction of wolves, grizzly bears, and jaguars into the area.
While they cannot accomplish these goals in one swipe, radical environmental groups feel they can methodically accomplish their goal by chipping away and gaining one piece of their ultimate goal at a time (closing of one road at a time, removing grazing from one allotment at a time, etc.). Actions from local Forest Service officials over the past decade indicate a willingness to help the environmental groups attain their objectives.
The Martinez family has ranched and paid taxes in Greenlee County for 160 years. They are award-winning stewards of the land and have spent thousands of their hard-earned dollars on range improvements that help wildlife as well as livestock. Their operation has historically been considered a model for good management. They have received letters from former Forest Service officials commending their good management. They are considered ranchers that have always “played by the rules”.
It is no secret that any time you decide to “take on” the federal government you are going to have your hands full. So why have the Martinez’s drawn a line in the sand with the Forest Service? First, they too understand that Greenlee County has been targeted for a large endangered species refuge and want to help reverse the disturbing trend.
Second, they believe the Forest Service should be able to transfer their grazing permit from father to son without infringing on their private rights. They have refused to sign the waiver that they believe would endorse a reduction in their permit as well as take away rights associated with their allotment. The Martinez family is not claiming that they own the land, only that they have private property (rights) associated with the land. They will pay grazing fees when presented with a bill.
So where should Greenlee County get involved in all of this? Arguments can be made for or against county intervention on the very complex issue of the property rights claims. The courts will ultimately answer the property rights questions arising from the Martinez claims.
However, the issue of impounding and selling the Martinez cattle, is another matter. I believe there are numerous actions our Sheriff and County Attorney could have and should have attempted in an effort to stop this negative fiasco from occurring. Let me explain:
1. The agreement between the Forest Service and the Arizona Department of Agriculture created a double standard for the impoundment of livestock; the agreement allows the Forest Service to sell the cattle without a court order. Yet, a court order is required for the Arizona State Land Department to impound and sell livestock on Arizona State lands; a court order is also required before a financial institution can gather and sell cattle from a ranch that has defaulted on a loan. Why then, should the Forest Service be allowed to gather and sell cattle without a court order?
Our government is a system of checks and balances. The question arises, “When the State decided to make a political decision on this issue, why didn’t the County Attorney and Sheriff challenge the validity of the agreement and subsequent impoundment?” After 160 years of being good citizens of this county has the Martinez family not earned at least that much?
All property owners live in some degree of fear that the Federal government will someday find a reason to take his or her property. It certainly does not seem unreasonable to require a court order for the confiscation and selling of private property. The Sheriff and County Attorney could have easily taken a stand on behalf of the property owners in Greenlee County and told the Forest Service that no cattle would be taken from this county without a court order.
2. It appears that the gathering and attempted sale of the Martinez cattle is intended to bring down one of Greenlee County’s cornerstone families and to permanently dismember their livestock operation. There were avenues available to the Forest Service to avoid the impoundment, but they chose not to utilize them. Some options include:
-Forest Service grazing permits have been transferred from one owner to another in other Forest Districts without signing a waiver. (I recently talked to a rancher who has done it).
-The Forest Service can also allow a permittee to let another rancher run cattle on his/her allotment. An agreement to let the son run cattle on the father’s ranch could have been an option. This has occurred on one of the neighboring allotments.
Did our elected leaders (Sheriff and County Attorney) ever tell the Forest Service they would like to try to find a way to avoid the impoundment?
3. While they were gathering the cattle, the Forest Service closed the Rattlesnake Gap road. This occurred during deer hunting season. Why was the road closed? Shouldn’t that action have been challenged on behalf of the citizens of Greenlee County?
4. The Forest Service hired armed federal law enforcement to protect Forest Service employees and the contractors hired to gather the cattle. Why? The Martinez family has no history of violence. Many citizens have pointed out how intimidating it is to have these armed federal employees in our community. Shouldn’t the Sheriff have challenged that action to avoid such an ugly scene in our county.
Because they have the most power to represent our interests, we look to our elected officials to stand up on our behalf and protect our rights. The impoundment of the Martinez cattle is probably the most negative event to occur in Greenlee County in decades and could likely have been avoided with minimal intervention from county elected officials.
Our Sheriff and County Attorney are our most powerful county elected officials in these matters. Citizens in this area understand that challenging the federal government is a tough task, and we know we’re not going to win every battle. Property owners do however, want to know that if the federal government finds a reason to take their property, our county officials will do everything they can to protect them. The current feeling is that the lack of action by our County Attorney and Sheriff is helping the Forest Service in their apparent attempt to bring down the Martinez family. Effort is all we are asking for, but to this point it really has not been there.
Jeff Menges
Local Rancher
SATURDAY NIGHT AT THE WESTERNER
The barn
by Larry Gabriel
The barn is a unique place. The barn served many purposes in rural life and was a top priority investment to our farmers.
When the sky is grey with swirling snow and the temperature hovers around zero and the wind is howling, stepping into a well-built barn filled with hay and animals is a joy.
The amount of warmth produced by the livestock is surprising and a welcome relief to the owner checking his stock. The animals are safe and they know it. Maybe all living things need a barn of some kind when the storms of life are raging. The barn is a safe haven.
The aroma of alfalfa, feed and animals is largely unnoticed at the time, but lingers for decades in the back of a mind and may return when recalling memories of youthful times spent in a barn.
After a month or so of deep winter, children escape the house and turn the hay loft into a gigantic playground, swinging from the hay ropes and wrestling for king of the hill.
When the blizzards roll down the plains and snow drifts become too deep for equipment to move feed, the livestock are kept safe behind the barn.
Windbreaks around the barns shelter animals from the storm. Hay thrown from the loft by hand provides the calories to keep them warm.
Back when almost every farm produced both grains and livestock the barn was the heart of the farm and often it cost more than the house. The enormous red barn with a gambrel roof was a necessity to many in those days.
Our language is filled with hints of the importance of the barn. If you leave the door open someone might ask if you were "born in a barn". If something is really big, it might be "big as a barn". If something was very exciting it might be a "real barn burner".
"Barn raisings" were important community social events and a means of welcoming new members. It is too bad we don't have more barn raisings, because they provide a social benefit worth more than the barn.
Nothing bonds people with each other like working together to build a tangible product. That is how we "build" farm families. That is how we "build" our communities. We bond through joint efforts.
The process of building something together creates the bonding of a family or community. The thing being built is less important than the process.
Each community and each new generation in that community needs a "barn raising".
There are many efforts to preserve the old barns, but maybe it is time to build some new ones.
Larry Gabriel is the South Dakota Sec. of Agriculture
Axe handle reputations are made in the line of duty
By Julie Carter
Reputations are made in a number of ways. Some are established over a life time of works, good or bad, and sometimes the distinction will come from a single moment in time without real word or surmised deed.
The bitter cold that has gripped the country this week induced thoughts of those folks that daily handle an axe. Breaking ice on livestock waters and splitting firewood are a few basics in this world that remain the same today as they did a century or more ago.
Out in the panhandle of Texas, as I write, stand thousands and thousands of cattle on wheat pasture in someone’s care. And yes, this very morning, those folks are making their “circle” -- breaking ice, checking hot fence wires and a given, doctoring sick yearlings. Sub-zero temperatures are no excuse to stay home by the fire.
A few years back a couple I know was well into a long winter of heavy snow with plenty of ice and mud. They had been in the wheat cattle pasture business for a number of years, had good reputations for be fair wheat traders, quality pasture managers and just being generally honest folk.
On this particular day, the little woman, in both name and size, had made her circle which involved 65 miles of road driving. It entailed riding through 18 pastures checking for sick cattle and breaking ice on the troughs in each pasture. She had one more to go. Her good roan horse had been in and out of the stock trailer so many times on that long day he decided to not be in a particular hurry to unload.
Her “tired” was hanging out as much as the roan’s but the job was to be done. Standing on the fender of the trailer and reaching through the slats, the cowgirl used the handle end of her ice breaking axe to try to snare the reins on the horse’s neck. While she was encouraging him to back out of the trailer, the farmer who owned that particular wheat pasture land happened by.
The cowgirl had the business end of the axe in her gloved hands, but the farmer was unable see that. He slowed his pickup to view the action then quickly sped away as fast as the snow and mud would allow. Not giving it a thought, she got the horse unloaded and went about her business.
The next morning midway through her circle, she stopped by the grain elevator to get a hot cup of coffee and thaw out by the ever-blazing stove. As she walked in, all the domino players stood up. Ordinarily she would only get a nod and a hello from them, so the standing ovation caused her to ask what was up.
“Lyndon was by here yesterday and said he saw you hit your good horse in the head with an ax because he wouldn’t unload,” said one of men gathered at the elevator. “Everybody knows how much you love that roan horse, so we figured if you are that tough, we better come to attention when you walk in.”
The cowgirl just laughed at them and never told them any different. That little smidgen of fear could be used to every last bit of advantage over the coming years.
copyright Julie Carter 2005
The barn
by Larry Gabriel
The barn is a unique place. The barn served many purposes in rural life and was a top priority investment to our farmers.
When the sky is grey with swirling snow and the temperature hovers around zero and the wind is howling, stepping into a well-built barn filled with hay and animals is a joy.
The amount of warmth produced by the livestock is surprising and a welcome relief to the owner checking his stock. The animals are safe and they know it. Maybe all living things need a barn of some kind when the storms of life are raging. The barn is a safe haven.
The aroma of alfalfa, feed and animals is largely unnoticed at the time, but lingers for decades in the back of a mind and may return when recalling memories of youthful times spent in a barn.
After a month or so of deep winter, children escape the house and turn the hay loft into a gigantic playground, swinging from the hay ropes and wrestling for king of the hill.
When the blizzards roll down the plains and snow drifts become too deep for equipment to move feed, the livestock are kept safe behind the barn.
Windbreaks around the barns shelter animals from the storm. Hay thrown from the loft by hand provides the calories to keep them warm.
Back when almost every farm produced both grains and livestock the barn was the heart of the farm and often it cost more than the house. The enormous red barn with a gambrel roof was a necessity to many in those days.
Our language is filled with hints of the importance of the barn. If you leave the door open someone might ask if you were "born in a barn". If something is really big, it might be "big as a barn". If something was very exciting it might be a "real barn burner".
"Barn raisings" were important community social events and a means of welcoming new members. It is too bad we don't have more barn raisings, because they provide a social benefit worth more than the barn.
Nothing bonds people with each other like working together to build a tangible product. That is how we "build" farm families. That is how we "build" our communities. We bond through joint efforts.
The process of building something together creates the bonding of a family or community. The thing being built is less important than the process.
Each community and each new generation in that community needs a "barn raising".
There are many efforts to preserve the old barns, but maybe it is time to build some new ones.
Larry Gabriel is the South Dakota Sec. of Agriculture
Axe handle reputations are made in the line of duty
By Julie Carter
Reputations are made in a number of ways. Some are established over a life time of works, good or bad, and sometimes the distinction will come from a single moment in time without real word or surmised deed.
The bitter cold that has gripped the country this week induced thoughts of those folks that daily handle an axe. Breaking ice on livestock waters and splitting firewood are a few basics in this world that remain the same today as they did a century or more ago.
Out in the panhandle of Texas, as I write, stand thousands and thousands of cattle on wheat pasture in someone’s care. And yes, this very morning, those folks are making their “circle” -- breaking ice, checking hot fence wires and a given, doctoring sick yearlings. Sub-zero temperatures are no excuse to stay home by the fire.
A few years back a couple I know was well into a long winter of heavy snow with plenty of ice and mud. They had been in the wheat cattle pasture business for a number of years, had good reputations for be fair wheat traders, quality pasture managers and just being generally honest folk.
On this particular day, the little woman, in both name and size, had made her circle which involved 65 miles of road driving. It entailed riding through 18 pastures checking for sick cattle and breaking ice on the troughs in each pasture. She had one more to go. Her good roan horse had been in and out of the stock trailer so many times on that long day he decided to not be in a particular hurry to unload.
Her “tired” was hanging out as much as the roan’s but the job was to be done. Standing on the fender of the trailer and reaching through the slats, the cowgirl used the handle end of her ice breaking axe to try to snare the reins on the horse’s neck. While she was encouraging him to back out of the trailer, the farmer who owned that particular wheat pasture land happened by.
The cowgirl had the business end of the axe in her gloved hands, but the farmer was unable see that. He slowed his pickup to view the action then quickly sped away as fast as the snow and mud would allow. Not giving it a thought, she got the horse unloaded and went about her business.
The next morning midway through her circle, she stopped by the grain elevator to get a hot cup of coffee and thaw out by the ever-blazing stove. As she walked in, all the domino players stood up. Ordinarily she would only get a nod and a hello from them, so the standing ovation caused her to ask what was up.
“Lyndon was by here yesterday and said he saw you hit your good horse in the head with an ax because he wouldn’t unload,” said one of men gathered at the elevator. “Everybody knows how much you love that roan horse, so we figured if you are that tough, we better come to attention when you walk in.”
The cowgirl just laughed at them and never told them any different. That little smidgen of fear could be used to every last bit of advantage over the coming years.
copyright Julie Carter 2005
OPINION/COMMENTARY
Media Fish Fry
The week before Thanksgiving, the World Wildlife Fund, an environmental NGO got what it wanted in the lead up to the United Nations' latest meeting to discuss climate change, taking place in Montreal -- scary stories about dire effects from global warming. "WWF: World's Fish Are In Hot Water," CBSNews reported. "Group: Higher Water Temps Threaten Fish," intoned ABCNews International and MSNBC. "Global Warming Threatens Fish," FoxNews declared. All the major networks carried headlines about the WWF's report: Are We Putting Our Fish In Hot Water? The report itself was filled with lots of glossy pictures, lots of information on the importance of fishing to diets and the world economy, and lots of scary speculation about what might happen if waters are allowed to warm more than 2 degrees Celsius. The only thing lacking was scientific documentation to warrant such a media frenzy. If the media really wanted to know what is going on with fish it might have attended the International Council for the Exploration of the Seas 2004 workshop, "The Influence of Climate Change on North Atlantic Fish Stocks," in Bergen, Norway, or at least reviewed some of the more than three dozen scientific studies and reports presented there. Then they would know how simplistic and misleading WWF's generalizations are. Consider WWF's supposed fishery expert Katherine Short's bald statement: "The balance is set to tip, as climate change continues the pressure on fish populations already strained by overfishing, pollution and habitat loss." What fish populations is she talking about? Salmon? Arctic char? Cod? Haddock? Tuna? All of them are reviewed in the 2004 workshop, and there was no evidence that man-made climate change is or will have any major impact....
PICK UP A RIFLE
Unchecked by predators, deer populations are exploding in a way that is profoundly unnatural and that is destroying the ecosystem in many parts of the country. According to Nicholas D. Kristof of the New York Times, we should bring back hunting and reestablish a balance in the natural world. In a wilderness area, there might be 10 deer per square mile, but in parts of New Jersey, there are up to 200 per square mile. The exploding deer populations are harming humans, says Kristof:
* More Americans are killed by deer each year than by any other large American mammal, including bears, cougars and wolves.
* A study for the insurance industry estimated that deer kill 150 people a year in car crashes nationwide and cause $1 billion in damages.
* Ticks and Lyme disease, a more indirect effect from deer, also kill humans.
Agreeing on a solution for controlling deer populations and protecting humans has proven difficult. These days, among the university-educated crowd in the cities, hunting is viewed as barbaric. Towns in New York and New Jersey are talking about using birth control to keep deer populations down, although deer contraception has not been very successful. Meanwhile, some towns are paying big bucks, taking out contracts on deer through discreet private companies. Kristof says this is ridiculous. We have an environmental imbalance caused in part by the decline of hunting, he says. Humans first wiped out certain predators -- like wolves and cougars -- but then expected their own role as predators to sustain a rough ecological balance. The humane and green solution, says Kristof, is to encourage hunting, and many environmentalists agree. Deer are not pets, and many find hunting them is preferable to letting deer die of hunger and disease. Furthermore, hunting connects people with the outdoors and creates a broader constituency for wilderness preservation.
For text: Nicholas D. Kristof, "For Environmental Balance, Pick Up a Rifle," New York Times, December 4, 2005.
For text (subscription required):
http://select.nytimes.com/2005/12/04/opinion/04kristof.html?hp&oref=login
Senator Bingaman's Bogus Climate Proposal
U.S. Senator Jeff Bingaman (D-NM) is scheduled to deliver a speech at the UN global warming meeting in Montréal this afternoon on his plan for mandatory carbon dioxide emissions controls in the United States. If similar to proposals Sen. Bingaman intended to offer earlier this year in the Senate, the plan would represent significant economic sacrifice without measurably reducing global greenhouse gas emissions. “While Sen. Bingaman’s approach has been presented as a moderate and sensible response to the possibility of global warming, it clearly is neither,” said Competitive Enterprise Institute Director of Global Warming Policy Myron Ebell. “If Bingaman were taking the alarmist position held by supporters of the Kyoto Protocol seriously, his plan would be far too modest to be of any value. If he were concerned about its economic impact, it would be far too expensive.” Sen. Bingaman’s proposed amendment to energy legislation this summer was withdrawn once it became clear that it would be defeated. It represented a scaled-back version of carbon dioxide emissions limits first advanced by Senators John McCain (R-AZ) and Joseph Lieberman (D-CT). The McCain-Lieberman amendment was defeated by 38 votes to 60 in the Senate and itself represented a much-reduced version of the emissions reductions which would have been called for had the U.S. Senate ratified the Kyoto Protocol. “Bingaman’s approach would be both expensive and useless, making it difficult to believe he takes even his own current position seriously,” continued Ebell....
More Than One Best Way
A new consensus is emerging at the United Nations' Climate Change Conference in Montreal. Some participants are beginning to recognize that the Asia-Pacific Partnership for Clean Development and Climate Change (AP6) is at least part of the way forward in a global effort to deal with any potential harms from man-made global warming. The AP6 was announced last summer and includes China, India, South Korea, Japan, Australia, and the United States. The goal of the AP6 is to address climate change by focusing on creating and deploying technologies that emit less greenhouse gas such as carbon dioxide. Dr. Shin Boo-nam, the deputy director general of South Korea's ministry of foreign affairs and trade explained, during a panel discussion organized by the International Council for Capital Formation, that the AP6 members aim to use technological innovation and cooperation to improve their energy security, reduce air pollution, and address climate change. The goals of the AP6 appear to be aligned with the new proposals for combining economic development and climate policies being offered by various participants in the Montreal conference. For example, the environmental think tank the World Resources Institute issued a new study that focuses on how to boost the economic growth of poor countries while simultaneously helping them improve their energy efficiency. The report, Growing in the Greenhouse: Policies and Measures for Sustainable Development while Protecting the Climate, offers a series of case studies in which fast growing countries like China and India are urged to adopt policies that encourage both economic growth and energy efficiency. The WRI calls this sustainable development policies and measures (SD-PAMs). The idea is that developmental paths are favored that result in significantly lower future greenhouse gas emissions....
An Unethical Environment?
I've been thinking a lot lately about people who - -despite living in industrialized countries -- find affluence and the associated consumption of natural resources troubling. By their lights, wealthy countries like the US are the world's principle consumers -- unfairly rich, winners of life's lottery, polluters of the environment and so on. They claim that rich countries wish to "impose" their way of life on the rest of the world. Maurice Strong, for example -- long an influential executive officer at the U.N. and the head of the 1992 Earth Summit -- once said: "Isn't the only hope for the planet that the industrialized civilizations collapse? Isn't it our responsibility to bring that about?" In his book Earth in the Balance, Al Gore (who could easily be the US president right now) advocated "bold efforts to change the very foundation of civilization." What motivates these people? Have they tried poverty and decided that poverty is better than wealth? I doubt it. The poor of the world aspire to gain what we have. Many will risk their lives (some will lose their lives) to enter the United States to be able to enjoy what we frequently take for granted. The single most important underlying theme that unites these critics of affluence is a misunderstanding of basic economics. I'm not talking about the intricacies of economic theories and their associated technical buzzwords. I'm talking about concepts that are so basic to the health and happiness of a society that they should be taught in every high school -- perhaps before.....
Media Fish Fry
The week before Thanksgiving, the World Wildlife Fund, an environmental NGO got what it wanted in the lead up to the United Nations' latest meeting to discuss climate change, taking place in Montreal -- scary stories about dire effects from global warming. "WWF: World's Fish Are In Hot Water," CBSNews reported. "Group: Higher Water Temps Threaten Fish," intoned ABCNews International and MSNBC. "Global Warming Threatens Fish," FoxNews declared. All the major networks carried headlines about the WWF's report: Are We Putting Our Fish In Hot Water? The report itself was filled with lots of glossy pictures, lots of information on the importance of fishing to diets and the world economy, and lots of scary speculation about what might happen if waters are allowed to warm more than 2 degrees Celsius. The only thing lacking was scientific documentation to warrant such a media frenzy. If the media really wanted to know what is going on with fish it might have attended the International Council for the Exploration of the Seas 2004 workshop, "The Influence of Climate Change on North Atlantic Fish Stocks," in Bergen, Norway, or at least reviewed some of the more than three dozen scientific studies and reports presented there. Then they would know how simplistic and misleading WWF's generalizations are. Consider WWF's supposed fishery expert Katherine Short's bald statement: "The balance is set to tip, as climate change continues the pressure on fish populations already strained by overfishing, pollution and habitat loss." What fish populations is she talking about? Salmon? Arctic char? Cod? Haddock? Tuna? All of them are reviewed in the 2004 workshop, and there was no evidence that man-made climate change is or will have any major impact....
PICK UP A RIFLE
Unchecked by predators, deer populations are exploding in a way that is profoundly unnatural and that is destroying the ecosystem in many parts of the country. According to Nicholas D. Kristof of the New York Times, we should bring back hunting and reestablish a balance in the natural world. In a wilderness area, there might be 10 deer per square mile, but in parts of New Jersey, there are up to 200 per square mile. The exploding deer populations are harming humans, says Kristof:
* More Americans are killed by deer each year than by any other large American mammal, including bears, cougars and wolves.
* A study for the insurance industry estimated that deer kill 150 people a year in car crashes nationwide and cause $1 billion in damages.
* Ticks and Lyme disease, a more indirect effect from deer, also kill humans.
Agreeing on a solution for controlling deer populations and protecting humans has proven difficult. These days, among the university-educated crowd in the cities, hunting is viewed as barbaric. Towns in New York and New Jersey are talking about using birth control to keep deer populations down, although deer contraception has not been very successful. Meanwhile, some towns are paying big bucks, taking out contracts on deer through discreet private companies. Kristof says this is ridiculous. We have an environmental imbalance caused in part by the decline of hunting, he says. Humans first wiped out certain predators -- like wolves and cougars -- but then expected their own role as predators to sustain a rough ecological balance. The humane and green solution, says Kristof, is to encourage hunting, and many environmentalists agree. Deer are not pets, and many find hunting them is preferable to letting deer die of hunger and disease. Furthermore, hunting connects people with the outdoors and creates a broader constituency for wilderness preservation.
For text: Nicholas D. Kristof, "For Environmental Balance, Pick Up a Rifle," New York Times, December 4, 2005.
For text (subscription required):
http://select.nytimes.com/2005/12/04/opinion/04kristof.html?hp&oref=login
Senator Bingaman's Bogus Climate Proposal
U.S. Senator Jeff Bingaman (D-NM) is scheduled to deliver a speech at the UN global warming meeting in Montréal this afternoon on his plan for mandatory carbon dioxide emissions controls in the United States. If similar to proposals Sen. Bingaman intended to offer earlier this year in the Senate, the plan would represent significant economic sacrifice without measurably reducing global greenhouse gas emissions. “While Sen. Bingaman’s approach has been presented as a moderate and sensible response to the possibility of global warming, it clearly is neither,” said Competitive Enterprise Institute Director of Global Warming Policy Myron Ebell. “If Bingaman were taking the alarmist position held by supporters of the Kyoto Protocol seriously, his plan would be far too modest to be of any value. If he were concerned about its economic impact, it would be far too expensive.” Sen. Bingaman’s proposed amendment to energy legislation this summer was withdrawn once it became clear that it would be defeated. It represented a scaled-back version of carbon dioxide emissions limits first advanced by Senators John McCain (R-AZ) and Joseph Lieberman (D-CT). The McCain-Lieberman amendment was defeated by 38 votes to 60 in the Senate and itself represented a much-reduced version of the emissions reductions which would have been called for had the U.S. Senate ratified the Kyoto Protocol. “Bingaman’s approach would be both expensive and useless, making it difficult to believe he takes even his own current position seriously,” continued Ebell....
More Than One Best Way
A new consensus is emerging at the United Nations' Climate Change Conference in Montreal. Some participants are beginning to recognize that the Asia-Pacific Partnership for Clean Development and Climate Change (AP6) is at least part of the way forward in a global effort to deal with any potential harms from man-made global warming. The AP6 was announced last summer and includes China, India, South Korea, Japan, Australia, and the United States. The goal of the AP6 is to address climate change by focusing on creating and deploying technologies that emit less greenhouse gas such as carbon dioxide. Dr. Shin Boo-nam, the deputy director general of South Korea's ministry of foreign affairs and trade explained, during a panel discussion organized by the International Council for Capital Formation, that the AP6 members aim to use technological innovation and cooperation to improve their energy security, reduce air pollution, and address climate change. The goals of the AP6 appear to be aligned with the new proposals for combining economic development and climate policies being offered by various participants in the Montreal conference. For example, the environmental think tank the World Resources Institute issued a new study that focuses on how to boost the economic growth of poor countries while simultaneously helping them improve their energy efficiency. The report, Growing in the Greenhouse: Policies and Measures for Sustainable Development while Protecting the Climate, offers a series of case studies in which fast growing countries like China and India are urged to adopt policies that encourage both economic growth and energy efficiency. The WRI calls this sustainable development policies and measures (SD-PAMs). The idea is that developmental paths are favored that result in significantly lower future greenhouse gas emissions....
An Unethical Environment?
I've been thinking a lot lately about people who - -despite living in industrialized countries -- find affluence and the associated consumption of natural resources troubling. By their lights, wealthy countries like the US are the world's principle consumers -- unfairly rich, winners of life's lottery, polluters of the environment and so on. They claim that rich countries wish to "impose" their way of life on the rest of the world. Maurice Strong, for example -- long an influential executive officer at the U.N. and the head of the 1992 Earth Summit -- once said: "Isn't the only hope for the planet that the industrialized civilizations collapse? Isn't it our responsibility to bring that about?" In his book Earth in the Balance, Al Gore (who could easily be the US president right now) advocated "bold efforts to change the very foundation of civilization." What motivates these people? Have they tried poverty and decided that poverty is better than wealth? I doubt it. The poor of the world aspire to gain what we have. Many will risk their lives (some will lose their lives) to enter the United States to be able to enjoy what we frequently take for granted. The single most important underlying theme that unites these critics of affluence is a misunderstanding of basic economics. I'm not talking about the intricacies of economic theories and their associated technical buzzwords. I'm talking about concepts that are so basic to the health and happiness of a society that they should be taught in every high school -- perhaps before.....
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)