Sunday, November 17, 2013

Trail Dust: Wrangler turned author once fled New Mexico

by Marc Simmons


Southern New Mexico’s cowboy novelist Eugene Manlove Rhodes surely rates as one of the most eccentric authors ever to inhabit the state. Seems everyone who knew him had a story or two about his quirky behavior.

Even now, I occasionally run into someone in Santa Fe who remembers Gene when he lived and wrote briefly in Tesuque, just north of town, during the 1930s. Inevitably, they’ll tell me of some odd thing he said or did.


Gene grew up working as a horse wrangler on ranches in the Tularosa Basin and along the Jornada del Muerto. His father briefly served as agent for the Mescalero Apaches.
The country was still part of the Wild West, and the young Rhodes did his part in making it wooly. He was constantly in fistfights and shootouts. Late in life, he would say that in his youth, he had witnessed 13 men killed.

The curious thing about this feisty horse wrangler was that he loved to read. When not working, he always had a book in his hand. Most often it was a paper-bound classic ordered through the mail and paid for with coupons that came in those days with each sack of Bull Durham tobacco.

When traveling, Rhodes usually carried a gunny sack full of books tied to his saddle. Once he rode 25 miles in a snowstorm reading Shakespeare and scarcely noticing the cold. He would sit for hours in an old tin bathtub, with his nose buried in a book...

Gene owned a hardscrabble outfit in the San Andres Mountains, near the edge of the White Sands. He had an ongoing feud with large rancher Watson Ritch, son of a former territorial governor. Rhodes claimed that in time, he had eaten 181 of Rich’s cattle.

On several occasions, Rhodes tried to force Rich into a gunfight, but failed. Years after Gene had left New Mexico, he learned that Watson Ritch intervened to bail his widowed mother (the elder Mrs. Rhodes) out of a financial scrape. Gene wrote his old foe a letter of apology and declared, “The hatchet is buried!’

“The Four Rannyhands:” Harry Carey, Eugene Manlove Rhodes, Fred Stone, and Charles M. Russell eating grub at Carey’s ranch, 1923


In 1906, Gene fled New Mexico under mysterious circumstances and went to live for the next quarter-century in his wife’s home town of Apalachin, N.Y. Several different stories suggest the reason for his hasty departure.

One is that his habit of rustling stock finally caught up with him, and he left the territory just a step ahead of the sheriff. Another tale has it that he bent his gun barrel over the head of a local tough named Kentucky Hargis, and that incident prompted him to leave.

The most widely accepted theory holds that his flight was prompted by a fight at Oro Grande, a mining town on the road between Alamogordo and El Paso.

There, Rhodes got into a fight with a large man in a crap game. They adjourned out back to finish their argument and, being outsized, the smaller horse wrangler evened the odds by breaking several beer bottles over his opponent’s head. Thinking he had killed the fellow, so the story goes, Gene headed east before he could be arrested.

During his long exile in New York, he wrote and published eight novels and 30 short stories. He always said that he dreamed night and day of his old life in New Mexico, and that his writings about the glorious West provided him a measure of comfort...

Gene Rhodes died in 1934 and is buried inside the boundaries of the White Sands Missile Range. One of his books, Pasó Por Aquí, is regarded as a classic of New Mexican literature.



No comments: