William Perry Pendley
It is a cliché that the main stream media get much wrong,
infuse news with opinions, and—what they do not get wrong or slant—they
miss entirely. Nonetheless, it is nothing short of amazing they failed
to report the most outsized match since Goliath, the Philistine
champion, sneered contemptuously at ruddy-faced David, the shepherd
boy. After all, when three poor rural counties in a remote corner of a
western state sue a who’s who of the world’s most powerful organizations
and a billion-dollar corporation, that is news!
That was not the media’s reaction when those groups, the corporation,
and a few American Indian tribes filed federal lawsuits against
President Donald J. Trump. When those lawsuits were filed reporters—who
love every lawsuit, regardless of legal merit, filed against
Trump—heaped on the praise. Another reason they did so was the suits
challenged President Trump’s reductions of two national monuments in
Utah created (illegally say most experts) by President Clinton in 1996
and President Obama in 2016 at the behest of environmental groups, media
darlings all. Finally, the bicoastal media elite’s distain for—when
they think of us at all—fly-over-country, the Mountain West, and rural
Utah is positively breathtaking.
There is no excusing, however, the failure of the media to reveal the
real target of the lawsuits, that is, some of the hardest working,
poorest, and longest suffering descendants of some of the West’s oldest
families: the men, women, and children of Garfield, Kane, and San Juan
Counties. After all, the lawsuits demand they stop ranching and
farming, logging and mining, searching for sources of energy, and
recreating on the vast, wide-open federal lands they and their ancestors
have used, in full compliance with federal law, for many generations.
What is it they are to do instead? Pump gas, pull espressos, and
fluff duvets or otherwise serve the tourists who, although promised
after the Clinton shut down of 1.9 million acres in 1996, never came.
Even if they had, as western third-generation logger Bruce Vincent said
when a similar disaster befell his tiny town, “You have to sell a lot of
t-shirts to replace a job in the mill.” Just who are these Goliaths
that so denigrate rural Utahns?
The Natural Resources Defense Council, as of 2015, had revenue of
$130 million and assets of three times that amount. The Sierra Club the
same year raised nearly $110 million with assets of $82 million. That
year, the National Trust for Historic Preservation raised nearly $52
million and boasted assets of nearly $296 million. Who knows how much
they are worth today? All totaled, they and the groups allied with them
in their lawsuits raised $390 million for the latest year available and
bragged of assets of more than $855 million. At the head of the parade
is the most admirable, self-made, billionaire owner of Patagonia, a
self-described “dirtbag” who once spent over 200 nights a year sleeping
outdoors. Sadly, he and the groups with which he is allied think all
should live his lifestyle.
As outrageous as is the demand by the multi-million-dollar
environmental groups and the billionaire ascetic for the future of the
families of rural Utah is the legal holding they want federal courts to
adopt: No president’s actions may be reversed by a future president!
It sounds like The Ten Commandments when Pharaoh shouts: "So
let it be written. So let it be done." But presidents—no matter how
exalted by the media—are not pharaohs; nothing is written in stone—even
the Constitution can be amended; and illegal acts must be rectified.
President Trump was right to review abuses of the Antiquities Act of
1906. No one was surprised the review found Clinton and Obama violated
the law, single-mindedly pursued “environmental legacies,” and kowtowed
shamelessly to demands by radical environmental groups. Now however,
rural Utah is fighting back on its way to the Supreme Court.
For more information: Wilderness Society v. Trump
Issues of concern to people who live in the west: property rights, water rights, endangered species, livestock grazing, energy production, wilderness and western agriculture. Plus a few items on western history, western literature and the sport of rodeo... Frank DuBois served as the NM Secretary of Agriculture from 1988 to 2003. DuBois is a former legislative assistant to a U.S. Senator, a Deputy Assistant Secretary of Interior, and is the founder of the DuBois Rodeo Scholarship.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment